Lets wrap up Islamiat Paper: you have doubts post them and get the solutions

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

So, if we had to write about COMMUNAL LIFE!
Why are Dr.Iftikhar and Sir muzammil.. saying INDIVIDUAL LIFE -.-
What is going on?

 

[Irfan Atique]

couldn,t agree with u more.......tht was the actual requirement ......it was tricky coz we have to write individual conduct towards community

That is correct!

 

[Irfan Atique]

So, if we had to write about COMMUNAL LIFE!
Why are Dr.Iftikhar and Sir muzammil.. saying INDIVIDUAL LIFE -.-
What is going on?

they are wrong read the question..... and what Omar said is excellent.....
Q. From the set Hadith, Outline the teachings about conduct of Individual Muslims IN A COMMUNITY. (10)
Individual Muslims have two types of conducts.
The first one is that of their Private life, I.e Individual Life... Prayer, Earning Money Lawfully, Reading Quran (Hadis about Tethered Camels)
This Conduct is no way related to the COMMUNITY. One reading the Quran, doesnt benefit or effect the community.
The Second is related to the Community. I.e Communal Life. As in, How a Muslims Individual is supposed to Act and behave IN THE COMMUNITY. The responsibilities of a Muslim Individual as a member of the COMMUNITY. How his actions should be towards his fellow community members IN A COMMUNITY.

So the question clearly asked us to write about the conduct of Individual Muslims, IN A COMMUNITY.
As in, How a muslim individual should behave and act in an Islamic Community.
We had to write about Modesty, Brotherhood, Kindness, Mercy.. towards fellow members of the community. Because that is how the CONDUCT of an Individual Muslim should be while in a COMMUNITY.( omar is right...... ur teachers are wrong)

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

That is what i said

they are wrong read the question..... and what Omar said is excellent.....
Q. From the set Hadith, Outline the teachings about conduct of Individual Muslims IN A COMMUNITY. (10)
Individual Muslims have two types of conducts.
The first one is that of their Private life, I.e Individual Life... Prayer, Earning Money Lawfully, Reading Quran (Hadis about Tethered Camels)
This Conduct is no way related to the COMMUNITY. One reading the Quran, doesnt benefit or effect the community.
The Second is related to the Community. I.e Communal Life. As in, How a Muslims Individual is supposed to Act and behave IN THE COMMUNITY. The responsibilities of a Muslim Individual as a member of the COMMUNITY. How his actions should be towards his fellow community members IN A COMMUNITY.

So the question clearly asked us to write about the conduct of Individual Muslims, IN A COMMUNITY.
As in, How a muslim individual should behave and act in an Islamic Community.
We had to write about Modesty, Brotherhood, Kindness, Mercy.. towards fellow members of the community. Because that is how the CONDUCT of an Individual Muslim should be while in a COMMUNITY.( omar is right...... ur teachers are wrong)

 

[Irfan Atique]

ofcourse

AGREE

 

[Irfan Atique]

yar koi dam nahi hai,explain more the teachings of hadiths + u have to focus on individual conduct tht too related to community not towards Allah.....
Sorry i dont see enough in ur answer

THERE IS NOTHING TO BE MARKED FOR.... COZ EXPLANATION IS REQUIRED HOW N INDIVIDUAL WORK IN A COMMUNITY...... YOUR TEACHERS IS WRONG

 

[maya <3]

in p1 islamiyat was it the migration to yathrib??

 

[Irfan Atique]

That is what i said

I agree with you as well

 

[Irfan Atique]

in p1 islamiyat was it the migration to yathrib??

nop

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

Sir, why are the teachers wrong?
Aren't they the one's supposed to be right.
Aren't the teachers supposed to understand the question and interpret it.

 

[Irfan Atique]

in p1 islamiyat was it the migration to yathrib??

two events..... first background of what happened in boycott ...leads to the death of abutalib...... than in the given time line by the examiner... the events of taif n pledges of aqabah including the plotting of assassination of Prophet (S.A.W)

 

[Irfan Atique]

Sir, why are the teachers wrong?
Aren't they the one's supposed to be right.
Aren't the teachers supposed to understand the question and interpret it.

IF I SAY I GIVE YOU A GUN WITHOUT A BULLET WHAT WILL U DO?

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

I started off with background of boycott.. then told about Death of Abu Talib.. Loss of Tribal protection.. forced to Preach to Al-Taif.. and quoted his words at taif ''I hope their posterity will one day be among the believers in one Allah''... and then i told about pledges of Aqabah.. all the pledges with the number of pilgrims.. and then death plot.. and then quoted DIVINE REVELATION 8:30 marking the start of migration. Will i get 10/10?

two events..... first background of what happened in boycott ...leads to the death of abutalib...... than in the given time line by the examiner... the events of taif n pledges of aqabah including the plotting of assassination of Prophet (S.A.W)

 

[Irfan Atique]

Sir, why are the teachers wrong?
Aren't they the one's supposed to be right.
Aren't the teachers supposed to understand the question and interpret it.

TO become a teacher there is very specific branch of qualification called M.Ed.... in which we learn Bloom's Taxonomy in which they teach us how to make questions and how to understand a question....... i guess they haven't done this course that's why most of the teachers lack the ability of knowledge...all they have is a bookish knowledge which is not enough for teaching.

 

[Irfan Atique]

I started off with background of boycott.. then told about Death of Abu Talib.. Loss of Tribal protection.. forced to Preach to Al-Taif.. and quoted his words at taif ''I hope their posterity will one day be among the believers in one Allah''... and then i told about pledges of Aqabah.. all the pledges with the number of pilgrims.. and then death plot.. and then quoted DIVINE REVELATION 8:30 marking the start of migration. Will i get 10/10?

excellent answer bravo dear

 

[M.Omar]

they are wrong read the question..... and what Omar said is excellent.....
Q. From the set Hadith, Outline the teachings about conduct of Individual Muslims IN A COMMUNITY. (10)
Individual Muslims have two types of conducts.
The first one is that of their Private life, I.e Individual Life... Prayer, Earning Money Lawfully, Reading Quran (Hadis about Tethered Camels)
This Conduct is no way related to the COMMUNITY. One reading the Quran, doesnt benefit or effect the community.
The Second is related to the Community. I.e Communal Life. As in, How a Muslims Individual is supposed to Act and behave IN THE COMMUNITY. The responsibilities of a Muslim Individual as a member of the COMMUNITY. How his actions should be towards his fellow community members IN A COMMUNITY.

So the question clearly asked us to write about the conduct of Individual Muslims, IN A COMMUNITY.
As in, How a muslim individual should behave and act in an Islamic Community.
We had to write about Modesty, Brotherhood, Kindness, Mercy.. towards fellow members of the community. Because that is how the CONDUCT of an Individual Muslim should be while in a COMMUNITY.( omar is right...... ur teachers are wrong)

Thank u sir,tht is exactly wht i elaborated on........this wht seems and is logical

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

Exactly!
They have just a qualification of M.A Islamiat.
No M.Ed!

TO become a teacher there is very specific branch of qualification called M.Ed.... in which we learn Bloom's Taxonomy in which they teach us how to make questions and how to understand a question....... i guess they haven't done this course that's why most of the teachers lack the ability of knowledge...all they have is a bookish knowledge which is not enough for teaching.

 

[black widow]

sir, for question 2, i wrote
in the introduction that Prophet (S.A.W)'s communal life and qouted i quotation
in the second para, gave Hadith, "none of u believes until..", explained its theme and gave one quotation along with it . also wrote about how is it individual conduct in community
in third para, gave Hadith, "may God show mercy to man..", explained its theme and gave one quotation along with it . also wrote about how is it individual conduct in community
in fourth para, gave Hadith, "the one who takes care of the orphan and the poor man is like" . explained its theme and gave one quotation along with it . also wrote about how is it individual conduct in community
how much can i get?

 

[Irfan Atique]

Thank u sir,tht is exactly wht i elaborated on........this wht seems and is logical

yes it is correct and your understanding is better than the teachers...... i'll give you for this

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

So Sir, this type of confusion has never come up before in Islamiat paper.
I know numerous students who wrote about Individual Life.. and infact, Majority didn't write about Communal Life! They will all get Zero.