A level Islamic studies

[1995@10Sept]

^^^^^r those hadith which the sheeas quote correct..?? like that one which Salman al fasi (r.a) said..?? AAnsarii ...??/

 

[AppleCherries]

^^^^^r those hadith which the sheeas quote correct..?? like that one which Salman al fasi (r.a) said..?? AAnsarii ...??/

http://www.al-islam.org/encyclopedia/chapter6b/8.html i saw it on this website

 

[AppleCherries]

its the hadith of the prophet(pbuh) "after me there will be 30years of khilafa then there will be kingship"
30 years includde the four khulafa-e- rashideen n 'kingship' is the other sahabas ...like muawiah..yazid..ect
imaam mahdi is the twelve th imaam to b born in d end times..

Does it seem like an authentic source?

 

[fille spéciale]

Does it seem like an authentic source?

http://www.aqidah.com/creed/article...aafah-of-prophethood-that-lasted-30-years.cfm

 

[AAnsarii]

^^^^^r those hadith which the sheeas quote correct..?? like that one which Salman al fasi (r.a) said..?? AAnsarii ...??/

http://www.al-islam.org/encyclopedia/chapter6b/8.html i saw it on this website

perhaps they're claims of shi'as (apparantly) so maybe no problem. d 1st hadith appears in, as stated on d site, Sahih Baihaqi. haven't heard of it, bt is also in Musnad Ahmad. other ahadith do not appear 2 b authenticated. bt if u do have tym, cn state & say they even 2k not-very-authentic ahadith 2 support their Imamate, such was their love for them.
Do NOT get biased. May Allah Help us. & give us all all A*s. aameen.

 

[AAnsarii]

idk
for wat is it?

4 evidence of Shia Imamate

 

[AAnsarii]

Shafi'ee on Q&S
o Abt 200 citations from Quran in Risala
o Quran can only abrogate Quran…likewise Sunnah abrogates Sunnah … Quran abrogates Sunnah only after a Sunnah itself first abrogates the Sunnah. ie he believed Sunnah can't abrogate Quran. only distinction for sunnah also wahy.

 

[AAnsarii]

For Imaam Shafi please also explain this:
oQuran: Inheritance after debts and bequests… Sunnah: only a 1/3rd of property and debt precedence
oMas-h ruling only if in purified state…
oSunnah : inspired and is part of revelation

d 1st bullet: Quran jsut outlines dat inherit only after debts paid n will executed. Sunnah detailed - only will on 1/3rd of property. >enough.

 

[AAnsarii]

Shafi'ee on Sunnah
i. Independant src of law.
cz of vrs of Quran: 59:7, "Whatever d Msgr gives u, tk it, whatever he forbids u, abstain 4m it"
ii.Explaination of Quran.
cz Allah Said in S. Nahl 16:44, "...and V hv revealed 2 u(o Muhammad) d remembrance so dat u may mk clear 2 dem/explain 2 dem wt ws revealed 2 dem..."
also wanted only Sahih ahadith.
Q&S foundation of his thought

cn someone plz expand on this?
1995@10Sept AngelicBeauty

 

[AppleCherries]

Can somebody please provide me some quotes to write on Islamic teachings about living with other faiths?

 

[AppleCherries]

Shafi'ee on Sunnah
i. Independant src of law.
cz of vrs of Quran: 59:7, "Whatever d Msgr gives u, tk it, whatever he forbids u, abstain 4m it"
ii.Explaination of Quran.
cz Allah Said in S. Nahl 16:44, "...and V hv revealed 2 u(o Muhammad) d remembrance so dat u may mk clear 2 dem/explain 2 dem wt ws revealed 2 dem..."
also wanted only Sahih ahadith.
Q&S foundation of his thought

cn someone plz expand on this?
1995@10Sept AngelicBeauty

Please help?

 

[AAnsarii]

Many Muslim scholars regard al-Shafi’i as the most important of the early legal experts. Give reasons to agree or disagree with this judgement. [20]
dis qn has come 3 times since '03. examiners have always gotten "nt v satisfactory" answers. looked 4:
*based interpretations on Q&S
*limited use of analogy (Qiyas)
*but other 3 also put Q&S primary. explain hw differed
*he researched a lot. even I.Laith's & I.Zaid's Madhabs.

1995@10Sept AngelicBeauty AppleCherries @fille spéciale

 

[AppleCherries]

Many Muslim scholars regard al-Shafi’i as the most important of the early legal experts. Give reasons to agree or disagree with this judgement. [20]
dis qn has come 3 times since '03. examiners have always gotten "nt v satisfactory" answers. looked 4:
*based interpretations on Q&S
*limited use of analogy (Qiyas)
*but other 3 also put Q&S primary. explain hw differed
*he researched a lot. even I.Laith's & I.Zaid's Madhabs.

1995@10Sept AngelicBeauty AppleCherries @fille spéciale

Can somebody please provide me some quotes to write on Islamic teachings about living with other faiths?

 

[AngelicBeauty]

Can somebody please provide me some quotes to write on Islamic teachings about living with other faiths?

 

[AAnsarii]

Please help?

I. Shafi'ee was d most imp. is most imp also 4 r syllabus.
hw ws he different? primarily, he related Sunnah 2 Quran. split Sunnah in2 2 --
1. Sunnah dat ws an independent src of law. this is legislated in d Quran, S.Hashr ch 59 v 7, "Whatever d Msgr gives u, tk it; whatever he 4bids u, abstain 4m it". so Allah declared 2 follow d Msgr (Saws) [even through 4:59,"O u who believe, obey Allah n obey d Msgr n those in authority among u. n if u differ over a thing, return 2 Allah n His msgr..."]
2. Explaination of d Quran. dis is evidenced by S Nahl v 44 mentioned above. so Allah Instructs d Pr(s) 2 explain.
must accept wt d msgr says as wahy, cz Allah Said in S Najm v 3-4, "And he (Muhd.) does not speak of his own accord. it is nt but a revelation revealed".

he only put criteria 4 acceptance of hadith dat it should b Saheeh
d Quran & Sunnah 4md d basis of his interpretations n thus Madhab.
hope it helped. May Allah Help us all.

 

[AAnsarii]

Difference in Sunnah in d various madhabs' view:

• Hanafi = must b Mash-hoor
• Maliki = nt contradict Ijma of Madinites
• Shafi'ee = authentic
• Hanbali = attributed 2 d Pr(s) n nt fabricated. thus doubtful ahadith also madhab

Controversial sources of Islamic law:

1. Istihsan n Ijma of scholars--Hanafi Madhab
2. Istislah, Ijma of Madinites n customs--Maliki
3. Urf--Hanafi & Maliki
4. Weak ahadith--Hanbali

^in an answer asking 4 d differences in srcs of law, state d diff srcs n diff ways of interpreting d same src.

 

[AngelicBeauty]

Difference in Sunnah in d various madhabs' view:

• Hanafi = must b Mash-hoor
• Maliki = nt contradict Ijma of Madinites
• Shafi'ee = authentic
• Hanbali = attributed 2 d Pr(s) n nt fabricated. thus doubtful ahadith also madhab

Controversial sources of Islamic law:

1. Istihsan n Ijma of scholars--Hanafi Madhab
2. Istislah, Ijma of Madinites n customs--Maliki
3. Urf--Hanafi & Maliki
4. Weak ahadith--Hanbali

^in an answer asking 4 d differences in srcs of law, state d diff srcs n diff ways of interpreting d same src.

jazakAllah this is really gonna be of great help , 4,m where did u get this?
and i dint undersatnd hanbali attributed what to the prophet?

 

[AngelicBeauty]

Difference in Sunnah in d various madhabs' view:

• Hanafi = must b Mash-hoor
• Maliki = nt contradict Ijma of Madinites
• Shafi'ee = authentic
• Hanbali = attributed 2 d Pr(s) n nt fabricated. thus doubtful ahadith also madhab

Controversial sources of Islamic law:

1. Istihsan n Ijma of scholars--Hanafi Madhab
2. Istislah, Ijma of Madinites n customs--Maliki
3. Urf--Hanafi & Maliki
4. Weak ahadith--Hanbali

^in an answer asking 4 d differences in srcs of law, state d diff srcs n diff ways of interpreting d same src.

if they ask for difference , we have to only state difference in quran and sunnah or even the other sources that wer common???

 

[AAnsarii]

jazakAllah this is really gonna be of great help , 4,m where did u get this?
and i dint undersatnd hanbali attributed what to the prophet?

Evolution of Fiqh .....
I.Hanbal accepted ahadith attributed 2 d Pr(s)

 

[AngelicBeauty]

Evolution of Fiqh .....
I.Hanbal accepted ahadith attributed 2 d Pr(s)

matlab only those ahadith that speak about the prophet or only that which the prophet narrated???