4= A, cuz if 8 more electrons are present then it must be in the same group , and it could be a noble gas , or anything else , who knows?>..http://www.xtremepapers.com/papers/CIE/Cambridge IGCSE/Chemistry (0620)/0620_w09_qp_11.pdf
Please explain Q 4 and Q 23 !!
so both are correct.