Islamiat paper 2 discussion

[hamzashariq]

Im a little confused. isnt the 10 mark question supposed to be based on knowledge. How come the question " how can the lives of caliphs be a role model for leaders today" came as it is clearly an evaluative question and therfore should have come in part b.

 

[ZaMiN RaZa]

it was devised for those people who just memorize blindly and not evaluate accordingly or Rutoos in Pakistan is what we call them. but cie is just devising new questions along the way so dont say this was not according to the course.

 

[Starlight97]

yaa this time questions were quite new and difficult

 

[Shizza Jalil]

Yes, this question was quite different. Attempted it, only found points for Hazrat Abu Bakr and Umar. :/ What points were to be written for Hazrat Usman and Ali?

 

[Starlight97]

what about sahadad question ????

 

[Irtzavvv]

Yes, this question was quite different. Attempted it, only found points for Hazrat Abu Bakr and Umar. :/ What points were to be written for Hazrat Usman and Ali?

for usman he chose to die then shead muslim blood.. generosity he gave the his wealth away
HAZRAT ALI knowledge wisdom, bravery , gate of knowledge
democratic , right of non Muslims protected no violence no security guards , used to roam the streets it was such an easy question I JUST DESCRIBED THEIR ACT (like hazrat abu bakr taking 6000 drihams) AND TOLD HOW IT WAS APPLICABLE TO DAY (leaders should not be a burden on state fund and wast money on them )... just think of it as what they did and what ASIF ZARDARI does not do....I GAVE NO QUOTATION ALTHOUGH I KNEW IT IS IT COMPULSORY

 

[Irtzavvv]

IT was a difficult paper WHAT IS THE TYPE OF HADITH AND HOW ARE THEY CHECKED
DID YOU WRITE ABOUT SAHI FABRICATED HASAN DAEEF OR Qudsi ..nabi
I WROTE ONLY FIRST WITH HOW ISNAD AND MATN IS CHECKED is it OK again no quotation

 

[Shizza Jalil]

Types of Hadith : Authentic (Sahih), Approved (Hasan), Weak (Zaeef), Fabricated.
And yes, the main two points were those of Sanad and Matn, apart from that we had to elaborate these, in terms of the characteristics of each type.

 

[hussey96]

want some notes there bundles of notes for is islamiat have a look http://notes4-olevel.blogspot.com/

 

[hamzashariq]

it was devised for those people who just memorize blindly and not evaluate accordingly or Rutoos in Pakistan is what we call them. but cie is just devising new questions along the way so dont say this was not according to the course.

That's true. I did well in this question and wrote a good 2 pages on it. However, you can not deny the fact that it was based on evaluation and not on knowledge.

 

[FAizan007]

Yes, this question was quite different. Attempted it, only found points for Hazrat Abu Bakr and Umar. :/ What points were to be written for Hazrat Usman and Ali?

No that was wrong! that was to be discussed randomly not particularly but with the examples of particular caliph like 'Hazrat Umar's Majlis e Aam n Hazrat Abu Bakr's Majlis e Shura'

If u had done it particularly then there are chances of some falling marks

 

[Shizza Jalil]

Not particularly, I meant I found points about the first too which could set examples for leaders today.

 

[Irtzavvv]

Types of Hadith : Authentic (Sahih), Approved (Hasan), Weak (Zaeef), Fabricated.
And yes, the main two points were those of Sanad and Matn, apart from that we had to elaborate these, in terms of the characteristics of each type.

MY FRIENDS ON HADIS E QUDSI AND NABVI ONLY WHY YOU DID NOT WRITE THEM

 

[Shizza Jalil]

Well let's see what turns out right.

 

[qasim9]

Types of Hadith : Authentic (Sahih), Approved (Hasan), Weak (Zaeef), Fabricated.
And yes, the main two points were those of Sanad and Matn, apart from that we had to elaborate these, in terms of the characteristics of each type.

apart from these types of Hadith which u wrote !!
don't we have to write about Hadith Qudsi and Hadith Nabwi ??

 

[Shizza Jalil]

Well, I didn't write those.

 

[qasim9]

Well, I didn't write those.

me either
but mostly people are saying that we have to write it :/

 

[Shizza Jalil]

I didn't, consulted my sir about it later on, he said my answer was fine. So yeah..

 

[qasim9]

I didn't, consulted my sir about it later on, he said my answer was fine. So yeah..

Yeahh! Means my one is fine too
pretty relieved after hearing it thanks for telling

 

[Shizza Jalil]

Glad I helped.
Insha'Allah, we'll all get good grades. Amen.