Lets wrap up Islamiat Paper: you have doubts post them and get the solutions

[M.Omar]

to yaaar marks to do na

I aint examiner however..........................4 or 5 may be

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

aoa im a student of sir muzammil mehmood is asked him he siad that it was individual conduct however i want you to evaluate my answer

Prophet said," The world is the cultivating ground for the hereafter". So every muslim is prescribed with some individual responsibilities and will be held accountable for that.

A hadith follows,
" A man asked the messenger of Allah,' do you think if i perform obligatory prayers keep fasts in ramadhan and treat as lawful that which is lawful and treat as unlawful that which is unlawful shall i enter paradise?' prophet replied yes" The hadith emphasises upon performing obligatory prayers keeping fasts and distinguish between haram and halal.

A person should always be ready to strive hard in Allahs way as prophet said," the most excellent of men is the one who strives hard in allahs way wit his person and property". So men should keep themselves away from evil inclinations and should never be reluctant in spending wealth in his way. Similarly prophet of allah empahasised upon the dignity of labour as he said" no one eats better food than which he eats out of the work of his own hand.

Modesty is an obligation on a believer. Prophet said"Modesty produces nothing but good". So a person should be modest towards his Allah his friends and members of opposite sex. they should be humble and never should be arrogant.

Actions are judged by intentions so a person if does a good deed should do it for the sake of allah as it is told by prophet," God does not regard at your appearences and possessions but he looks at your hearts and actions." Similarly it is told to live lives according to Allahs orders as Propehet said,"the world is the believers prison and the unbelievers paradise".

So every muslim is responsible and he should fulfill his her responsibilities as prophet said," Every one of you is responsible and you will be questioned about your responsibility".


SO this was my answer pls evaluate it i will be thankful to you

The only Hadith relevant to a Muslims responsibility to the community is the one you mentioned about MODESTY.
So i'd give you not more than 2 or 3 marks!
The whole answer revolves around things like Prayer, Individual responsibilities, Earning Lawful money.
All that is no way related to the community. Sorry!

 

[yousaf masood]

o

The only Hadith relevant to a Muslims responsibility to the community is the one you mentioned about MODESTY.
So i'd give you not more than 2 or 3 marks!
The whole answer revolves around things like Prayer, Individual responsibilities, Earning Lawful money.
All that is no way related to the community. Sorry!

k and if for example it is individual conduct then how many marks?

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

Then 8 or 9.

o
k and if for example it is individual conduct then how many marks?

 

[M.Omar]

o
k and if for example it is individual conduct then how many marks?

then 7 i think

 

[Mustafa Abbasi]

The only Hadith relevant to a Muslims responsibility to the community is the one you mentioned about MODESTY.
So i'd give you not more than 2 or 3 marks!
The whole answer revolves around things like Prayer, Individual responsibilities, Earning Lawful money.
All that is no way related to the community. Sorry!

The earning lawfull money is actually correct BUT ONLY if we explain it like this"an individual today should be self-sufficeient and shud not rely upon others in the community unnecessarily"<this explain how the conduct shud be of an indivuidual in the community(not putting burden on others), similarly we could write about removing evil in the community,mercy,brotherhood,sincerity towards rulers and people,
The "striving hard with person and property" can also be correct if we explained it right..... for exp as we say" an individual should spend his wealth to improve social conditions and shud establish a community based on justice and righteousness'

SO THE CONCLUSION IS THAT THE MARKS DEPEND ON HOW WE EXPLAINED THE HADIS BECAUSE MOST OF THE HADIS IN THE SYLLABUS CAN BE WRITTEN FOR BOTH COMMUNITY AND INDIVIDUAL LIFE.

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

Each of those 20 Ahadith can be moulded up and presented in a way that they are beneficial for the community!
Even the Hadith about prayer.. can be said in the way that Praying in Congregation binds the community together.. and promotes equality, brotherhood.
Even Fasting can be told off in a way that the rich experience what it is like to be hungry and it removes the barrier between rich and poor to lead to development of the Community and Strong sense of love and unity.
So each of those Hadith has an advantage for Communal Life.
But we have to write those Hadith that are specific towards COMMUNAL LIFE and CONDUCT TOWARDS OTHER MEMBERS OF THE COMMUNITY.
I.E Brotherhood, Mercy, Kindness, Respect, Love.

The earning lawfull money is actually correct BUT ONLY if we explain it like this"an individual today should be self-sufficeient and shud not rely upon others in the community unnecessarily"<this explain how the conduct shud be of an indivuidual in the community(not putting burden on others), similarly we could write about removing evil in the community,mercy,brotherhood,sincerity towards rulers and people,
The "striving hard with person and property" can also be correct if we explained it right..... for exp as we say" an individual should spend his wealth to improve social conditions and shud establish a community based on justice and righteousness'

SO THE CONCLUSION IS THAT THE MARKS DEPEND ON HOW WE EXPLAINED THE HADIS BECAUSE MOST OF THE HADIS IN THE SYLLABUS CAN BE WRITTEN FOR BOTH COMMUNITY AND INDIVIDUAL LIFE.

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

And even those Hadith you say are quoted, they should be explained with that specific angle in which they are beneficial for the community. If the person quotes a Hadith about Individual life and explains the advantage to the Individual than that won't get marks.

 

[Mustafa Abbasi]

And even those Hadith you say are quoted, they should be explained with that specific angle in which they are beneficial for the community. If the person quotes a Hadith about Individual life and explains the advantage to the Individual than that won't get marks.

i agree with u, thats why i explained those hadis in the way they benefit commnity,we basically had to say abt what an individual has to do for the community(not overburden,remove evil,mercy,brotherhood,sincerity,spending wealth)

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

Exactly.

i agree with u, thats why i explained those hadis in the way they benefit commnity,we basically had to say abt what an individual has to do for the community(not overburden,remove evil,mercy,brotherhood,sincerity,spending wealth)

 

[Eimaan Aamir]

I screwed my Q4 in Islamiat Paper1 by writing about Makkah rather than Madina Will I still be able to get an A*? The rest of my Questions went Awesome.

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

I screwed my Q4 in Islamiat Paper1 by writing about Makkah rather than Madina Will I still be able to get an A*? The rest of my Questions went Awesome.

No, A* is gone.

 

[Eimaan Aamir]

Is an A possible?

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

Let's say you get a 0/10 in that Paper 1 Question 4.
You get 7/8 in Question 1, 9/10 and 3/4 in Question 2, 0/10 and 3/4 in Question 4 and Let's say 12/14 in the other question.
So you get around 34-36/50!
If you get around 44-46 in Paper2, then you get an A.

Is an A possible?

 

[Eimaan Aamir]

My Sit said that even if you get 36 and 36 in both Papers, an A is easily Awarded..

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

Getting 36 in both papers, means 72%!
This time both papers were very easy.. I know some people who are getting Perfect marks!
Like all the questions were repeated from past papers.
People wrote answers perfectly getting 10/10 in most questions.
So the Percentile will be higher.

But still its possible.
I hope so!
My Paper 2 was not at all good :/

My Sit said that even if you get 36 and 36 in both Papers, an A is easily Awarded..

 

[Eimaan Aamir]

Ehh, I don't know. This was such a Stupid Mistake and I feel Like Dying
I really wanna kill Myself

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

That Paper 1 Question 4 mistake, was indeed very stupid. I agree!
But Nothing can be done now.
You'll get around 44 in Paper 1 and 36 in Paper 2!
So it'll be an A easily.
And even if you get 76-78%, Thanks to percentile that would be an A.

Ehh, I don't know. This was such a Stupid Mistake and I feel Like Dying
I really wanna kill Myself

 

[yousaf masood]

I must confirm that dr iftikhar also expressed the same opinion as sir muzammil so ab yeh satare apni kahir manaye

 

[Irfan Atique]

what else was to be written in communal life? obviously the conduct of muslims in that, no ? :s

every individual in the the community....according to the question