• We need your support!

    We are currently struggling to cover the operational costs of Xtremepapers, as a result we might have to shut this website down. Please donate if we have helped you and help make a difference in other students' lives!
    Click here to Donate Now (View Announcement)

need help in pak studies!!! :\

sana akbar

sana akbar

Messages
20
Reaction score
13
Points
3
plx guys help mee... there wux a question in past paper:

Q.Abolition of caliphate was the main reason of failure of khalifat movement. do you agree? (14)
look i koe that it was the main reason but i dont know how to comprehend the answer and how to elaborate the abolition !!
 
M

MuslimGirl

Messages
1,829
Reaction score
10,424
Points
523
sana akbar said:
plx guys help mee... there wux a question in past paper:

Q.Abolition of caliphate was the main reason of failure of khalifat movement. do you agree? (14)
look i koe that it was the main reason but i dont know how to comprehend the answer and how to elaborate the abolition !!
Click to expand...
Umm... Did you see the Marking scheme? If not, Then do, It'll Help, IA. :)
If further help is needed...You can Pm me... :)
 
Umna.Asim

Umna.Asim

Messages
447
Reaction score
608
Points
103
Question: Was the abolition of caliphate the main reason for the failure of the Khilafat Movemment? Do you agree ? Discuss.

Answer: The Khilafat movement was started by maulana Muhammad Ali and maulana Shaukat Ali. It was aimed against the British government to save the Caliphate in turkey. The first khilafat conference was in 1919. It was the first political Movement started by the Muslims which made them politically aware and helped them to organize themselves. However this movement failed due to some reasons.

The main reason that I think for the failure of this movement was the abolition of Khilafat by Kemal ataturk. The main objective of the Muslims in this movement was to save the khilafat in turkey. The khilafat was an identity for the Muslims and held a great symbolic value for them. Kemal ataturk when came to power,he wanted to introduce western ideas in his country as he wanted turkey to be westernized so when he abolished caliphate it gavea devastating blow to the Muslims as they now thought that There was no use in continuing this movement anymore because the Turks had themselves destroyed it. Now they were too much engulfed in shock and their objective for the movement was finished so there was no use for them to make the movement go any longer and it failed.

Another reason was the calling off of satyagraha by gandhi. The movement was becoming too violent according to Gandhi. There was communal rioting everywhere between the Muslims and the Hindus. One such thing happened at chauri chauri in which an angry burnt 22 policemen. Gandhi was outraged at seeing this because he wanted a peaceful demonstration but it was getting out of hand. So hence, he decided to call it off after which the movement lost its momentum and the Muslims started blaming the Hindus for their betrayal at a critical stage. So the communal violence became more because of this and the movement failed.

Another reason for the failure of the khilafat movement was the hijrat movement. People had started blindly migrating to Afghanistan and they thought that just like Prophet Muhammad S.A.W was welcomed in Medina they would be welcomed too however they were not and the Afghanis sent them back. The people had agreed to blindly migrate to medina by selling their things and when they returned they saw that their things were in the hands of others and the people faced an enormous economic loss and the trust of the Movement's leaders was lost and the movement lost its popularity.

By concluding these points it can be said that the Abolition of Caliphate by kemalataturk was the major factor for the failure of the movement. Since it was the main objective on which the movement was launched so when it was itself finished the Muslims were quite shocked and the movement resulted in a failure.
 
sana akbar

sana akbar

Messages
20
Reaction score
13
Points
3
t
Umna.Asim said:
Question: Was the abolition of caliphate the main reason for the failure of the Khilafat Movemment? Do you agree ? Discuss.

Answer: The Khilafat movement was started by maulana Muhammad Ali and maulana Shaukat Ali. It was aimed against the British government to save the Caliphate in turkey. The first khilafat conference was in 1919. It was the first political Movement started by the Muslims which made them politically aware and helped them to organize themselves. However this movement failed due to some reasons.

The main reason that I think for the failure of this movement was the abolition of Khilafat by Kemal ataturk. The main objective of the Muslims in this movement was to save the khilafat in turkey. The khilafat was an identity for the Muslims and held a great symbolic value for them. Kemal ataturk when came to power,he wanted to introduce western ideas in his country as he wanted turkey to be westernized so when he abolished caliphate it gavea devastating blow to the Muslims as they now thought that There was no use in continuing this movement anymore because the Turks had themselves destroyed it. Now they were too much engulfed in shock and their objective for the movement was finished so there was no use for them to make the movement go any longer and it failed.

Another reason was the calling off of satyagraha by gandhi. The movement was becoming too violent according to Gandhi. There was communal rioting everywhere between the Muslims and the Hindus. One such thing happened at chauri chauri in which an angry burnt 22 policemen. Gandhi was outraged at seeing this because he wanted a peaceful demonstration but it was getting out of hand. So hence, he decided to call it off after which the movement lost its momentum and the Muslims started blaming the Hindus for their betrayal at a critical stage. So the communal violence became more because of this and the movement failed.

Another reason for the failure of the khilafat movement was the hijrat movement. People had started blindly migrating to Afghanistan and they thought that just like Prophet Muhammad S.A.W was welcomed in Medina they would be welcomed too however they were not and the Afghanis sent them back. The people had agreed to blindly migrate to medina by selling their things and when they returned they saw that their things were in the hands of others and the people faced an enormous economic loss and the trust of the Movement's leaders was lost and the movement lost its popularity.

By concluding these points it can be said that the Abolition of Caliphate by kemalataturk was the major factor for the failure of the movement. Since it was the main objective on which the movement was launched so when it was itself finished the Muslims were quite shocked and the movement resulted in a failure.
Click to expand...
hanks this relli helped :)
 
exactiankid

exactiankid

Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Points
11
Guys ! Need help.I Am having problem with a question here it is :Q:Was the hijrat movement the most important factor of the failure of khilafat movement. (14) It would be helpful if someone give complete answer.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top