pakistan studies ......... no time left

[Silent Hunter]

hey guys whats the answer to the

Why was the 2 RTC of 1931 unsuccessful ?

marking schemes did not explain the points...........can anybody explain them? :unknown:

thanks in advance

 

[scouserlfc]

pretty easy.
1.Conservative won power replacing the labour govt which was thought to be too sypathetic to Indian demands while conservatives were not.
2.Gandhis attitude was awful he took a hard line against minorities and failed to recognize their rights by saying that he represented them and also he then after this didnt give his points and suggestions in the conference so the minorities agreement failed.

Hope u get it.

 

[Silent Hunter]

-gandhi rejected 14 points to be included in any future negotiations
-gandhi refused to accept rights of muslims?

is this correct?

 

[scouserlfc]

yup this aslso correct he wanted Nehru report in future constitution and yeah minority agreement u better write this word CIE have this in MS so u write this and examiner wont get confused it is same as rightsd

 

[AnGeL.Of.DaRkNeSs]

2 R.T.C was held between september and december 1931 a.Congress took part in it which showed some beacon of hope but Congress led by gandhi who declared himself sole representative of whole of india.mr gandhi failed to accept the role of minority communities in india and expressed the view that there was no minority problem in india and congresss represented whole of india.Liberal party was defeated in england and also gandhi wanted nehru report in future constitution THIS view was not accepted by most of members so nothing could be achieved regarding the future constitutions of india because of wrong and stubborn attitude of mrgandhi.MR gandhi failed to give any political suggestions to remove the problems of minorities and when minority leaders on the conference presented their joint demands it was discarded by mr gandhi.SO second rtc failed without achieving anything...

 

[Silent Hunter]

minority agrrement is same as rights for muslims or other minorities?

 

[AnGeL.Of.DaRkNeSs]

@ silent hunter muslims were not included in minority communities they were a second major people first one being indians...

 

[irzumalik]

by the way indians are all the people livin in india , so at that tym myslims were also indians!