• We need your support!

    We are currently struggling to cover the operational costs of Xtremepapers, as a result we might have to shut this website down. Please donate if we have helped you and help make a difference in other students' lives!
    Click here to Donate Now (View Announcement)

bond angle

Messages
2,619
Reaction score
293
Points
93
this is what i got from wikipedia but shouldn't it be close to that of water
 

Attachments

  • ll.jpg
    ll.jpg
    3.3 KB · Views: 119
Messages
234
Reaction score
7
Points
28
Bond pair / lone pair / bond angle / shape
2 0 180 linear
2 1 105 non linear
2 2 105 non linear
3 0 120 trigonal planar
3 1 107 trigonal pyramidal
3 2 90 T shaped
4 0 109.5 tetrahedral
4 1 - distorted tetrahedral
4 2 90 Square planer
5 0 90/120 Square pyramidal
5 1 90 trigonal bipyramidal
6 0 90 Octahedral

You can figer out shape and bond angle from the table
eg. H2S ....bond pair 2 and lone pair 2...thus bond angle is 105(104.5) nd the shape is nonlinear (bent or V shaped)
 
Messages
234
Reaction score
7
Points
28
I think the wikipedia is wrong because this table is from one of the chemistry book
 
Messages
133
Reaction score
47
Points
38
The larger the central atom is the less the hydrogens have to spread out (because the electron repulsions are smaller) and the smaller the resulting angle.

This explaination seems quite controversial to the A level Chem content, but u all know there are AlwAys some exceptions in all sciences....;p

This is an extract from another forum:

"You cannot extrapolate the VSEPRT to other molecules such as PH3 simply because the greater size of the phosphorus atom basically affects the inter electron pair repulsion.

It's all very well to say that NH3 is 107º therefore PH3 will be as also - it just isn't.. there are other factors to consider such as the polarised nature of the N-H bond when compared to the P-H bond. The H-P-H bond angle is 93.7º even though it is pyramidal

This also applies to H2S and H2O - they do not have the same bond angle.

The VSEPRT does not predict bond angles , rather it explains them based on some rather simplistic and easily understood "rules"

Just learn the simple molecules H2O, NH3, CH4, XeF4, etc but do not be at all surprised by seemingly similar molecules with very different bond angles."
 
Messages
2,619
Reaction score
293
Points
93
this is ok but PH3 bond angle u just mentioned is wrong according to 1 mcq that came
 

Attachments

  • jj.jpg
    jj.jpg
    8.9 KB · Views: 70
Messages
2,619
Reaction score
293
Points
93
ER says a lone pair of electrons is DEEMED to have greater repulsion than a bond pair....i think this ansers abt H2S case as well
 
Messages
133
Reaction score
47
Points
38
Check this out @ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phosphine
See the H-P-H bond angle given there as 93.5 degrees

This is anoth3r contradiction jux like H2S. The truth is that the cambrigde is afraid of facing the reality and tends to teach its students what is easy to understand, even if it's against the reality. Lemme elaborate wid a good example:- When we are young, we are told by our elders that the Earth is ROUND but when we grow older we find that actually it ain't ROUND, rather it's SPHERICAL.......;p
 
Messages
2,619
Reaction score
293
Points
93
i saw that phosphine bond angle from wiki b4 bt since there was an ans available in markscheme ......thats y i had to accept it
 
Top