History help on 2 questions ... :(

[Translucent231]

ok thanks... another question

do you agree that during second world war there was no significant progress towards independence in the sub-continent? explain your answer.[14]

is this question asking about independence of the subcontinent from british rule ?? or is it asking about independence of pakistan from the subcontinent ?????

 

[SalmanPakRocks]

Well Basically they are asking about the Indpendence of Pakistan !! In this Question you have to list down the events that occured between the period of World War II. Need more info about this just ask !!

 

[Translucent231]

ok then the main points shuld be this :

i disagree that there was no significant progress during the second world war,as some events did lead to progress towards independence to a certain extent.

1)day of deliverence, coz it showed that muslims were not having common ground with hindus.
2) pak resolution clear cut picture of muslim aims as they would only settle for independent state.
3)cripps mission no progress coz all rejected it ,, progress coz it recognized the importance of minorities.
4)quit india resolution , no progress coz it lead to wide spread arrests. british realized it was time for them to leave india
5)GJ talks, progress coz they league was accepted at an equal ground of importance in subcontinent's future. no progress coz they ended in failure due to conflicting views, even the conflicting views showed how different both nations were.
6)simla conference , progress coz muslims were givin equal status as hindus, no progress coz it failed when congres demanded right to elect muslim and also resented muslims being given equal status.

so overall we can judge that most events failed, however they did lead to some progress in terms of widening the gulf between the 2 nations


is this the correct answer :??? if not then plzz correct it

 

[SalmanPakRocks]

yeah your quite correct !!

 

[Translucent231]

pheww thanks boyyyy

 

[SalmanPakRocks]

No problem I'll give you 13 marks !!

 

[scouserlfc]

ill give u 14 yaar everything mentioned and u even told what were the success so well done

 

[SalmanPakRocks]

But the Cie never gives anyone full marks though his response was excellent !!