Pakistan Studies, Islamiyat and Urdu: Post your doubts here!

[scouserlfc]

Re: HISTORY Rare questions !!

Expalin all the success and failures of Rtcs

Success
1.Pehli me do cheesay decide hoi
2.dosri mein aik small cheez

failures
1.pehli me as something was decided but it was a failurte as probs of large magnitude not decide because of congress not present
2. dosri gandhi mya pagal ho gai thai aur conservative govt aa gai thee
3.Nothing decide no one attended and no Jinnah congress and league very few guys went

THen a statement tell me what u will write. >> ??

 

[SalmanPakRocks]

Re: HISTORY Rare questions !!

Success of first
-Federal system decide for india.
-Princes decided to join the federation.
failure
-Minority issue remained unsolved.

Success of Second
-Sindh,N.W.F.P, Orissa given full provincial status
Failure
-Harsh attitude of Mr.Gandhi led to its failure. Minority issue remained unsloved.

Third was just a formality

 

[rafae]

Re: HISTORY Rare questions !!

Salman, and Scouser, thanks for helping out, but I still have one query.
Like I know what the reasons are, but obviously this is a 14 marks question, and you need to explain these reasons.
I already know the reasons, but I don't know how to explain them. That is where I am asking for guidance.

 

[SalmanPakRocks]

Re: HISTORY Rare questions !!

E.g:
The First RTC was the most successful one as the Federal system of government for India was accepted. It was a big success for League as Congress, in Nehru report demanded Unicharay system of government.
this is explaination. work your way like this and tell that if one thing was accepted then why it was success or failure !! hope its clear now !! don't hesitate to further conform it !!

 

[scouserlfc]

Re: HISTORY Rare questions !!

u could go abt this i just did this question its in june 05 P1 Q 3 c
U write abt a RTc then tell abt its success.
the first RTC was held in london in 1930 the congress was absent but somethings were decided,it was decided that representative form of govt started at provincial level and that princes agreed to enter into a future Dominion in India if there rights recognised. Just describe this like Ml was delighted with this as it always wanted govt at provincial level and also thought some ground was made then switch to next one and then the last one then jusm to failures which would be long as there are many describe each and every failure like Er says most candidates just write the failure and left like Gandhi took a hardline on the minority talk and was rude no one mentions why he took a hard line he said that he represented INdia whole of it and thererfore no need to protect rights of any community/

 

[SalmanPakRocks]

Re: HISTORY Rare questions !!

yeah correct !!

 

[rafae]

Re: HISTORY Rare questions !!

No I understand it now .
Thank you for helping out guys, both of you.

 

[SalmanPakRocks]

Re: HISTORY Rare questions !!

anytime bro !!

 

[boxfire1995]

Re: HISTORY Rare questions !!

Hey, what should i write about pakistan's relations with world organizations? 14
And pakistans relations with UN?14
overview of functions of WHO, UNICEF... etc?14

Need help immediately.

 

[SalmanPakRocks]

Re: HISTORY Rare questions !!

World organizations include common wealth, UNO, SAARC, RCD etc.
For UN write that cease fire was arranged by UNO after pak-india war, Also that pakistan sent its troops in UNO to help African states gain Independence.

 

[mintchocolate4567]

Re: HISTORY Rare questions !!

in the syllabus it's written that candidates shud know abt "advantages and disadvantages of urdu as national language"
i can do the advantages part....bt need a lil' help with the disadvantages part...
anyone pleeeez

 

[SalmanPakRocks]

Re: HISTORY Rare questions !!

Disadvantage was that it caused conflict with Bengali's as they wanted it Bengali to be the national language !!

 

[Alchemist4lyf]

Re: HISTORY Rare questions !!

Two disadvantages would be enough...
1. Bengali's thing. It was a minor cause for the separation of East Pakistan.
2. The Promotion of other languages is slow and this causes resentment amongst people of different regions whose languages are not promoted. This is evident from revolts in 1972 in Sindh over people protesting on their languages not being given importance.
3. A national language is supposed to unite people, but the opposite has happened, as the language is forced on many people..

Hope it helps...

 

[SalmanPakRocks]

Re: HISTORY Rare questions !!

Two disadvantages would be enough...
1. Bengali's thing. It was a minor cause for the separation of East Pakistan.
2. The Promotion of other languages is slow and this causes resentment amongst people of different regions whose languages are not promoted. This is evident from revolts in 1972 in Sindh over people protesting on their languages not being given importance.
3. A national language is supposed to unite people, but the opposite has happened, as the language is forced on many people..

Hope it helps...

thanks

 

[scouserlfc]

Re: HISTORY Rare questions !!

Well ,
1.What was the importance of Govt. of India Act 1935 ? (7)

 

[mintchocolate4567]

Re: HISTORY Rare questions !!

someone plz answer these questions.....
Q1)was the use of modern machinery the only raeson which helped british to transform their role in india from merchants to empire builders .do u agree?explain.(14)
Q2)why did brit govt take tough measures to deal with hindu protests btw 1905 and 1911?(7)(we're gona mention swadeshi mov,assasination attempt on lord minto,...am i right?)
Q3)why did gandhi declare cripps mission 1942 as post dated cheque on a failing bank?(7)
Q4)was nehru report the most imp attempt to frame a ccnstitution btw 1927 and 1935.agreed?explain.(14)(its india act 1935,right?)

 

[sundalwahid]

Re: HISTORY Rare questions !!

guyss i found dat docterine of lapse and docterine of paramountacy is totalli diffrent...!!!!

 

[scouserlfc]

Re: HISTORY Rare questions !!

someone plz answer these questions.....
Q1)was the use of modern machinery the only raeson which helped british to transform their role in india from merchants to empire builders .do u agree?explain.(14)
Q2)why did brit govt take tough measures to deal with hindu protests btw 1905 and 1911?(7)(we're gona mention swadeshi mov,assasination attempt on lord minto,...am i right?)
Q3)why did gandhi declare cripps mission 1942 as post dated cheque on a failing bank?(7)
Q4)was nehru report the most imp attempt to frame a ccnstitution btw 1927 and 1935.agreed?explain.(14)(its india act 1935,right?)

for A2 yeah u mention all congress and hindu agitations with details.
A3.1.wanted independence immediately
2.He didnt trust british and their demands because of previous events.
Im thinking a reason more ill tell u wait

A4 no it was Nehru report because all indians agreed except some resistance of ML not govt of india act it was totally rejected.

 

[SalmanPakRocks]

Re: HISTORY Rare questions !!

these Questions came in my mocks !!

 

[ashiqbal]

Re: HISTORY Rare questions !!

Well ,
1.What was the importance of Govt. of India Act 1935 ? (7)

-in this act provinces were given autonomy for the first time. they could execute their own porgrams and frame own constitutions
-the eligibility of voting was raised after which 25% could vote, 5 times the people allowed to vote
-the system of diarchy was introduced at centre and federal system was introduced which gave the princes more say in how the country was run
-it was the constitution that was adopted as the interim constitution after the british left
-it was the last major constitution before british left