PHYSICS p42 GT

[boxfire1995]

You dont get the point. Leave it, examiner will decide.

They are ions which are charged.. Ion A is +2 charge Ion B is +1 charge

 

[talha196]

Charge on isotopes is same. You can google it. Isotopes have similar charge as neutrons have no charge. Then how can charge be different?

Bhai quest ma likha tha ions of same isotope. Kya ions +1 +2 ki state ma exist nahi kartay?

 

[TANJIAHOU]

Same isotopes have same mass

 

[TANJIAHOU]

Damn... Didn't read the question and realize they were ions of same isotope of same mass ==

 

[boxfire1995]

Chalo, mana they have different charge, now tell me buddy, do we multiply the nucleon no. With the unified atomic mass or the proton no? Since proton no. Remains the same. So tell me, can mass be different or not?

Bhai quest ma likha tha ions of same isotope. Kya ions +1 +2 ki state ma exist nahi kartay?

 

[TANJIAHOU]

Mass can be different. But question stated that the ions were from the same isotope. So mass is same for all ions

 

[talha196]

Chalo, mana they have different charge, now tell me buddy, do we multiply the nucleon no. With the unified atomic mass or the proton no? Since proton no. Remains the same. So tell me, can mass be different or not?

Kya charge sirf proton k gain or loss sa ata hai... ions form by gain and loss of electrons.

 

[boxfire1995]

Mass can be different. But question stated that the ions were from the same isotope. So mass is same for all ions

Dude! Isotopes have same proton number, YES, BUT when we find the mass of each isotope, we MULTIPLY the nucleon no. Which for EVERY isotope is different.

 

[TANJIAHOU]

And there is no way an isotope can have half the mass of another isotope

 

[boxfire1995]

Kya charge sirf proton k gain or loss sa ata hai... ions form by gain and loss of electrons.

You can agree to disagree.

 

[talha196]

And there is no way an isotope can have half the mass of another isotope

Exactly i was bout to say this.

 

[talha196]

Protons are never gained, firstly, basics of chemistry.

Bhai you have studied too much. Dimagh par zor na dalain apnay.

 

[TANJIAHOU]

Atoms of isotopes have same number of positively charged particles called protons but no net charge. When an isotope loses electrons, number of protons > number of electrons, it has a net positive charge.

 

[TANJIAHOU]

Zz he deleted his post... :-o

 

[Fatima Iftikhar]

Atoms of isotopes have same number of positively charged particles called protons but no net charge. When an isotope loses electrons, number of protons > number of electrons, it has a net positive charge.

but radius depends on mass too.

 

[TANJIAHOU]

Question stated ions were formed from atoms of the same type of isotope. So same mass for all ions

 

[nightmaressana]

Who in their right state of mind said protons are gained? :O

 

[nightmaressana]

Kya charge sirf proton k gain or loss sa ata hai... ions form by gain and loss of electrons.

If what you're saying is correct, then i need to have a talk with my teacher. He said mass was correct.

 

[TANJIAHOU]

Maybe he's right. If he is, we got to change our textbooks.

 

[TANJIAHOU]

If what you're saying is correct, then i need to have a talk with my teacher. He said mass was correct.

Wow... You have the exact question in your head?