Pakistan Studies, Islamiyat and Urdu: Post your doubts here!

[ISFSAT]

yea i read it .. last question
the question asked stages that led to compilation so why are we writing about Imam Bukhari's details too ?

Sorry my mistake...u r right we dont need to give details of sahih bukhari...instead just few lines that Muhammad bin Ismeal al Bukhari was the first to concieve the idea of the compilation of sahih ahadiths then his footsteps were followed by many other scohlars who made authorative collections...that are fours sunans and two sahihs...i hope u get it now...

 

[kathy nelson]

I wrote about both of them! Nooooo
Any clue how many marks i will get??

i hope you get full or close to that . . . maybe they'll deduct a mark for writing on both of them . . . . just hoping

 

[kathy nelson]

Exactly..
This question is easy
-You have to write that the Muhaddithin (Imam Bukhari etc) used several methods to check the authenticity of the hadith that they collected by dividing the hadith into Sanad and Matn. They checked that the chain of transmitters were not broken and that its text should not contradict the teachings of Quran, be against the family of Holy Prophet etc. Then the muhaddithin checked Asma-Ur-Rijal (the narrators) their biographies were collected to ensure that they were pious, had excellent memory, were not liers. I will post the complete answer for this after some time okay? Hope you understand what you actually have to write. : )

i agree with you
but I think the answer should also outline the companions' (including caliphs) role in the beginning, then move on to the time of Imam Bukhari and others
however, the answer should mainly concentrate on the way the Muhaditheen authenticated the ahadith, like you said
and no, in my point of view, there is no need of giving data about the Muhaditheen themselves

 

[xSabax]

^Yes. : ) We can write about the contributions of caliphs and others like Abu Huraira during holy prophet's time in the introductory paragraph.

 

[Fallen316]

i agree with you
but I think the answer should also outline the companions' (including caliphs) role in the beginning, then move on to the time of Imam Bukhari and others
however, the answer should mainly concentrate on the way the Muhaditheen authenticated the ahadith, like you said
and no, in my point of view, there is no need of giving data about the Muhaditheen themselves

^Yes. : ) We can write about the contributions of caliphs and others like Abu Huraira during holy prophet's time in the introductory paragraph.

in short , we have to write about compilation from HOLY PROPHET (S)'s death till 6 books.
now this includes companions and the followers of companions .. Right ?

 

[Snowysangel]

Could someone tell me what exactly is coming in isl paper 2? I had learnt everything for paper 1

 

[kathy nelson]

Could someone tell me what exactly is coming in isl paper 2? I had learnt everything for paper 1

Major teachings in the hadith of Prophet (SAW)
History and importance of Hadith
The 4 rightly guided caliphs
Articles of faith & pillars of Islam

 

[Snowysangel]

Major teachings in the hadith of Prophet (SAW)
History and importance of Hadith
The 4 rightly guided caliphs
Articles of faith & pillars of Islam

Thanks, but what about the wives, the companions etc?

 

[xSabax]

in short , we have to write about compilation from HOLY PROPHET (S)'s death till 6 books.
now this includes companions and the followers of companions .. Right ?

Yes you can..

 

[kathy nelson]

Thanks, but what about the wives, the companions etc?

They were in paper one dude

 

[ISFSAT]

in short , we have to write about compilation from HOLY PROPHET (S)'s death till 6 books.
now this includes companions and the followers of companions .. Right ?

exactly...this is what i meant by companions, suessors and then the sucessors of the sucessors

 

[xSabax]

Guys, can anyone answer this question?

Compare the main features of Sunni and Shia books of Hadith. [10]

 

[Fallen316]

Guys, can anyone answer this question?

Compare the main features of Sunni and Shia books of Hadith. [10]

whats difficult in that ??
write about the 6 authentic sunni books and the 4 shia books .. simple

 

[xSabax]

I do know that we have to mention the books but what exactly is meant by the features? :\

 

[SamiaSaad]

give descriptions of the way in which fasting and almsgiving is carried out among the muslims (10)
how do these two pillars keep the islamic community together? (4)

help plz

 

[Epiphany]

give descriptions of the way in which fasting and almsgiving is carried out among the muslims (10)

help plz

Two years back, I came across a .pdf ebook type, related to fasting. So easy and to-the point information. I'll just try to find it and upload it here.

 

[SamiaSaad]

I edited the post. The answer to my other question plz

 

[funky brat]

why did gandhi declare cripps mission 1942 as post dated cheque on a failing bank?(7)

 

[SamiaSaad]

why did gandhi declare cripps mission 1942 as post dated cheque on a failing bank?(7)

why asking history question when its over? =P

 

[SamiaSaad]

wht was q2 of geo paper...just couldnt recal it....

i just remember the part a of qs 2. it was the map i think =P