BAN MUSIC CAMPAIGN - For Muslim brothers and sisters

[Mustehssun Iqbal]

Yup..plz do...infact check it now...

....but you did say, it's not haram...didn't you..?

I said I'm not sure if it's halal or haram. Not haraam doesn't mean something is necessarily halaal. You know , I thought it's one of the things that lie between the halaal and haraam, by that I mean makrooh and those things. Like mangoes , I don't think it's stated in the Quran and Ahadith that mangoes are halaal or haraam, but you have to reflect. Same goes with computer , I don't know any verse or ahadith that says using computer is halaal or haraam. But you have to reflect( there are quotation(s) about reflecting). And I was/ am still under research. Allah knows best.
btw I'll just check the lecture now.

 

[Mustehssun Iqbal]

Yup..plz do...infact check it now...

....but you did say, it's not haram...didn't you..?

I'm listening to it , halfway through the lecture. taking a break now. Some of the things I don't agree to, like he said, music can't be used for good. well, it can! I am not a heavy listener of music, but I'm sure 90% of us here must have heard the song "Eye of the tiger" and 50% of us here are familiar with the songs of the Pakistani band "Junoon" who use Sufi messages as lyrics in their songs. I'm not saying it's correct! I'm not saying it's halaal! But here's a point , it can be used for good!

 

[Mustehssun Iqbal]

But I do agree on many parts of the lecture , don't get me wrong!

 

[Mustehssun Iqbal]

And I have a doubt about the thing he said in the beginning , that deep down you all know it's haraam. I don't think you can claim a thing to be haraam by just feeling it deep down.
I doubt that it's all about deep down, it's about knowledge! I am not defending music. But the thing is, when I try to look deep down, what I come to see is, it needs more research! And Allah knows best.

 

[XPFMember]

I'm listening to it , halfway through the lecture. taking a break now. Some of the things I don't agree to, like he said, music can't be used for good. well, it can! I am not a heavy listener of music, but I'm sure 90% of us here must have heard the song "Eye of the tiger" and 50% of us here are familiar with the songs of the Pakistani band "Junoon" who use Sufi messages as lyrics in their songs. I'm not saying it's correct! I'm not saying it's halaal! But here's a point , it can be used for good!

Well, to be honest, I don't know about them, so I won't comment about it...
And, anyway if it can be used for good, we should anyway not encourage it..cuz my Lord said it...there must definitely be some wisdom in it....

 

[badrobot14]

Well, to be honest, I don't know about them, so I won't comment about it...
And, anyway if it can be used for good, we should anyway not encourage it..cuz my Lord said it...there must definitely be some wisdom in it....

brownie surprize is 1 of my fav vids of sh. kamal em makki... hahaha
love it how disgusting he makes it.. esp the end!
I showed this to many of my cousins....!

 

[Mustehssun Iqbal]

Well, to be honest, I don't know about them, so I won't comment about it...
And, anyway if it can be used for good, we should anyway not encourage it..cuz my Lord said it...there must definitely be some wisdom in it....

hehehe this man's certainly hilarious and serious!
but, I hope I'm not ruining the fun, but I'm still not sure if music is haraam. The thing is , as he mentioned, his friend left movies but Kamal al Makki didn't tell him that it's prohibited because it was benifitting his friend. So in the same manner, I won't further my discussion, and I too agree to avoid music where possible .
I think the discussion started with music being haraam. I didn't say it's haraam , nor halaal. I was only trying to say that we should look it in deeper way that you can't just call it haraam just because it's bad( just like eating pan(non tobacco) ) , but I'm not sure. And on that note, about 25% of the xtremepapers community including my friends and smzimran
dragged me into a circle of people and tried to beat me down till I get the point

 

[Mustehssun Iqbal]

... didn't tell him that movies are not prohibited* ^

 

[Mustehssun Iqbal]

and I can guarantee that someone else later will misread my posts and drag me into the circle of these peaceful people again :/

 

[badrobot14]

hehehe this man's certainly hilarious and serious!
but, I hope I'm not ruining the fun, but I'm still not sure if music is haraam. The thing is , as he mentioned, his friend left movies but Kamal al Makki didn't tell him that it's prohibited because it was benifitting his friend. So in the same manner, I won't further my discussion, and I too agree to avoid music where possible .
I think the discussion started with music being haraam. I didn't say it's haraam , nor halaal. I was only trying to say that we should look it in deeper way that you can't just call it haraam just because it's bad( just like eating pan(non tobacco) ) , but I'm not sure. And on that note, about 25% of the xtremepapers community including my friends and smzimran
dragged me into a circle of people and tried to beat me down till I get the point

just listen to end of music lecture.... it will explain... scholars know that only if something seems bad you don't make it haram... they have knowledge and know ahadith... so don't worry about them, they know their job...

if even after that lecture you have problems being convinced try reading this fatwa Scholarly opinion on Music with evidences from Quran and Sunnah

haha, no one is beating you bro.. does it benifit any of them if you agree with their openion or stay away from music...???

 

[Spidey21]

Well, to be honest, I don't know about them, so I won't comment about it...
And, anyway if it can be used for good, we should anyway not encourage it..cuz my Lord said it...there must definitely be some wisdom in it....

i am sorry ... he tried to pass a great message but i certainly dont agree with him

 

[IGCSE O/L student]

assalamu alaikum dear brothers and sisters in Islam, I'm not sure if I posted this video in this thread before. i tried checking if I did, but there are too many pages, and I'm kinda lazy.
I'll post it again just to make sure you accept that music IS haraam:

 

[frozen sunlight]

I alhamdulilah have quit music thanx to the encouragement and help of badrobot14 and alhamdulilah i have never felt better
i am now closer to Allah and love listening to the quraan. So plz do take that small step and stop ure music addiction for ure benfit in this world and the hereaftar inshallah

 

[badrobot14]

I alhamdulilah have quit music thanx to the encouragement and help of badrobot14 and alhamdulilah i have never felt better
i am now closer to Allah and love listening to the quraan. So plz do take that small step and stop ure music addiction for ure benfit in this world and the hereaftar inshallah

Alhamdulillah, la hawlla wa la Quwwata illa billah!! That's great news keep it up! May Allah make you, me and muslims here steadfast upon Islam.. Aameen!

 

[frozen sunlight]

Alhamdulillah, la hawlla wa la Quwwata illa billah!! That's great news keep it up! May Allah make you, me and muslims here steadfast upon Islam.. Aameen!

Aameen and may u get the reward

 

[XPFMember]

AsSalamoAlaikum Wr Wb...

Awesome..!!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hIS5kPvXtHo&feature=relmfu

 

[Peaceful]

quitting music is a bit hard, but u can do it if u r committed to do so.

 

[muslimah here]

 

[Borakk]

What about birds chirping, raining, car horns and so on?

You know, they're music too.

 

[SilverCrest]

What about birds chirping, raining, car horns and so on?

You know, they're music too.

yes
but the music being talked about here is the one generated from stringed musical instruments
Muslim scholars believe Prophet Daud also had a musical voice..Anyways Birds glorify Allah when they chirp!

We bestowed on Dawud Our great favour: “O mountains and birds! Echo his songs of praise!” And We made iron malleable for him. (Surah Saba, 10)


please correct me if i am wrong