In your opinion?

[Rutzaba]

About your question; Why can't you get what you are asking for? How do you know you can't get it? Is the result of it being harmful to you has been resulted from Istikhara?
Remember, asking Allah for something is no sin. Infact Allah Himself States;
''Call on Me, and I Will Answer your call'.
However, I won't make further comments (I may misguide you probably) since the situation is not known.

wat if its an istikhara situation then?

 

[Rutzaba]

then you yourslelf have to choose between your wishes and betterment
nobody can help you there, that is the whole point

wat if i pray for it toturn out gud for me

 

[Faizan Muhammmad]

wat if i pray for it toturn out gud for me

that is also possible
But just one thing, there are no boundaries to wishing nor any restrictions of time and space
you are a writer, your wishes define you
So whatever you wish to do you will be defining yourself

 

[Dark Destination]

Re:Is it a sin to keep asking God for something that you cant get?
Firstly, it is never sinful to ask Allah for anything.. Only a foolish person (mentally retarded) will ask Allah for something Haram while knows about it. For example: Help me to commit zina, drink alcohol, etc.... And so as obvious, his prayers won't be accepted. There are some special etiquette's of making a perfect dua that is most likely to be accepted:::: http://islamqa.info/en/36902


Back to your question, what do you mean 'you can't get?' If it means that you think it's impossible for you to achieve like you expect A*s when you haven't studied at all, then it's never a sin. The point is that you should always constantly keep asking Allah for his help and yes, in Islam we believe in miracles. Whether you get A*s or not is not the point. Infact, you will be rewarded for making dua and remembering Allah. This is the beauty of Islam

The Prophet (sal Allahu alaihi wa sallam) said: “Man should call upon Allah alone to provide for all his needs, so much so that even if a shoe-lace is broken, he should pray to Allah to provide a shoe-lace, and if he needs salt, he should beseech Allah to send it to him.” [Tirmidhi]

Could you elaborate on this statement with an example:

Exactly. That's the purpose of life. (Y)
Asking Allah for help with all our problems. :')

 

[Thought blocker]

SO, I forgot to join you, I even forgot, what was the topic we are talking, gimme a brief summary, so that I can join this discussion.
P.S. I am bored of reading nowadays

 

[Dark Destination]

SO, I forgot to join you, I even forgot, what was the topic we are talking, gimme a brief summary, so that I can join this discussion.
P.S. I am bored of reading nowadays

What is the purpose of your existence?

 

[Thought blocker]

What is the purpose of your existence?

Acha, and what is the last thing we are talking on ?

 

[Dark Destination]

Acha, and what is the last thing we are talking on ?

Life.
It's a weird thing, isn't it?

 

[Thought blocker]

Life.
It's a weird thing, isn't it?

Lol, yup.. So what to discuss, we are just two - online in this thread

 

[Dark Destination]

Lol, yup.. So what to discuss, we are just two - online in this thread

I asked you a question a few minutes ago. Reply to that, maybe.

 

[Faizan Muhammmad]

Life.
It's a weird thing, isn't it?

I hate the irony it brings up every other moment (like them repeated questions in chm p4 )
But I still like its unpredictability (like Bio p2 )

 

[Thought blocker]

I asked you a question a few minutes ago. Reply to that, maybe.

Nah, I wont.

 

[Thought blocker]

Never assume that you're alone especially on the web. People watch and observe everything but not necessarily reply or give a feedback.

Okay, but I am not interested in this topic,

 

[Rutzaba]

Re:Is it a sin to keep asking God for something that you cant get?
Firstly, it is never sinful to ask Allah for anything.. Only a foolish person (mentally retarded) will ask Allah for something Haram while knows about it. For example: Help me to commit zina, drink alcohol, etc.... And so as obvious, his prayers won't be accepted. There are some special etiquette's of making a perfect dua that would be most likely to be accepted:::: http://islamqa.info/en/36902


Back to your question, what do you mean 'you can't get?' If it means that you think it's impossible for you to achieve like you expect A*s when you haven't studied at all, then it's never a sin. The point is that you should always constantly keep asking Allah for his help and yes, in Islam we believe in miracles. Whether you get A*s or not is not the point. Infact, you will be rewarded for making dua and remembering Allah. This is the beauty of Islam ... Moreover, CONSISTENCY is one of the keys of a dua being accepted. It's all about hope and trust that you have in Allah in such a way that you shouldn't doubt that your prayers are in vain or how many ever years it may take but Allah will listen and answer your duas. That should be the spirit!

The Prophet (sal Allahu alaihi wa sallam) said: “Man should call upon Allah alone to provide for all his needs, so much so that even if a shoe-lace is broken, he should pray to Allah to provide a shoe-lace, and if he needs salt, he should beseech Allah to send it to him.” [Tirmidhi]

Could you elaborate on this statement with an example: Neither Haram nor unlawful. But it has been made clear previously that it may not be good for me...

suppose i did istikhara... n then still i want that thing and i have no one else tro turn to excpt HIM but m praying the HE changes his decision :/

 

[Faizan Muhammmad]

suppose i did istikhara... n then still i want that thing and i have no one else tro turn to excpt HIM but m praying the HE changes his decision :/

How do you know the decision? Nobody has the knowledge of the future, so how can you ask it to be changed when you dont know what it was

 

[Rutzaba]

How do you know the decision? Nobody has the knowledge of the future, so how can you ask it to be changed when you dont know what it was

there are ways in wch Allah shows his people of the thing asked that is wat the purpose of istikhara is

 

[Dark Destination]

there are ways in wch Allah shows his people of the thing asked that is wat the purpose of istikhara is

What is Istikhara?

 

[Faizan Muhammmad]

there are ways in wch Allah shows his people of the thing asked that is wat the purpose of istikhara is

just do what your instinct says, it is too complicated for us as we have no knowledge

 

[Rutzaba]

just do what your instinct says, it is too complicated for us as we have no knowledge

instincts or wishes?

 

[Rutzaba]

What is Istikhara?

asking Allāh to guide one to the right sort of action concerning an important endeavour. A two rak‘a prayer is offered for this purpose with a special du‘ā (supplication)