Pakistan Studies, Islamiyat and Urdu: Post your doubts here!

Messages
25
Reaction score
1
Points
13
hi guys i really need help with the 14 mark question of history. Do you write success and failure in one para or do u divide the success and the failure in different paras. pls reply asap
 
Messages
499
Reaction score
416
Points
73
hi guys i really need help with the 14 mark question of history. Do you write success and failure in one para or do u divide the success and the failure in different paras. pls reply asap
one paragraph or different paragraph it doesnot makes a difference ......i used to do it in different paragraphs
 
Messages
25
Reaction score
1
Points
13
can somebody pls upload sir Iftikhar ul haq section 3 notes. PLsssssss. Would really appreciate it
 
Messages
129
Reaction score
23
Points
18
hi guys i really need help with the 14 mark question of history. Do you write success and failure in one para or do u divide the success and the failure in different paras. pls reply asap
Hi, As per the format given in the past papers and the one taught by the school, I have the following information;

-For a 14 mark question total of 7 explanations are required.
- Successes and Failures shall be written in the ratio 4:3 or 3:4, 4 successes, 3 failures, and vice versa.
-Paragraphing is encouraged; ensures presentation and easier to read style. Explain each success and failure in a separate paragraph.
-Successes are written first and failures afterward.
-Evaluate the successes and failures; as of why is it a success or failures, describe the impact of the situation in general.
i.e. 1937 election made the Muslims realize that their support lied in areas where they were in a minority THIS LED the Muslims to realize that they need to carry out mass campaigning in minority areas to earn greater support.
i.e. Minorities agreement was signed between Nehru of India and Liaquat Ali Khan. It guaranteed the protection of religious minorities. THIS HELPED to slow down the tide of refugees.

*- However for questions relevant to early ministries i.e. Ayub khan, Zulfiqar, etc. (Pakistani governments till 1999), we were asked to evaluate the successes and failures of their policies side by side. i.e. in the same paragraph, particularly for Ayub and Zia.
- In this case, there will be 7 paragraphs accounting for 7 successes and failures described in one paragraph.

*This is the format I follow, only a recommendation and not a compulsion. Do get it verified from your subject teacher especially.
 
Messages
25
Reaction score
1
Points
13
Hi, As per the format given in the past papers and the one taught by the school, I have the following information;

-For a 14 mark question total of 7 explanations are required.
- Successes and Failures shall be written in the ratio 4:3 or 3:4, 4 successes, 3 failures, and vice versa.
-Paragraphing is encouraged; ensures presentation and easier to read style. Explain each success and failure in a separate paragraph.
-Successes are written first and failures afterward.
-Evaluate the successes and failures; as of why is it a success or failures, describe the impact of the situation in general.
i.e. 1937 election made the Muslims realize that their support lied in areas where they were in a minority THIS LED the Muslims to realize that they need to carry out mass campaigning in minority areas to earn greater support.
i.e. Minorities agreement was signed between Nehru of India and Liaquat Ali Khan. It guaranteed the protection of religious minorities. THIS HELPED to slow down the tide of refugees.

*- However for questions relevant to early ministries i.e. Ayub khan, Zulfiqar, etc. (Pakistani governments till 1999), we were asked to evaluate the successes and failures of their policies side by side. i.e. in the same paragraph, particularly for Ayub and Zia.
- In this case, there will be 7 paragraphs accounting for 7 successes and failures described in one paragraph.

*This is the format I follow, only a recommendation and not a compulsion. Do get it verified from your subject teacher especially.

Thank u so much!!! Really cleared my confusion.
 
Messages
129
Reaction score
23
Points
18
Hi, Please answer the following 7 mark questions ;
Q. Why was Indian National Congress formed?
Q. Why did Sir Syed Ahmed Khan did not allow Muslims to join Indian National Congress?
^
These are 7 mark questions, 3 detailed and developed reasons are required.
Thank you.
 
Messages
13
Reaction score
1
Points
3
hi everyone, I need help in attempting this 14 mark question. Kindly help, would really appreciate it.
Q1-
Which of the following contributed the most to the establishment of a separate homeland for Muslims?
  • Gandhi-Jinnah Talks;
  • Simla conference;
  • Cabinet Mission plan?
Explain your answer with reference to all three of the above.
 
Messages
13
Reaction score
1
Points
3
hi everyone, I need help in attempting this 14 mark question. Kindly help, would really appreciate it.
Q1-
Which of the following contributed the most to the establishment of a separate homeland for Muslims?
  • Gandhi-Jinnah Talks;
  • Simla conference;
  • Cabinet Mission plan?
Explain your answer with reference to all three of the above.
CAN ANYONE HELPPPP
 
Messages
129
Reaction score
23
Points
18
CAN ANYONE HELPPPP
CAN ANYONE HELPPPP
hi everyone, I need help in attempting this 14 mark question. Kindly help, would really appreciate it.
Q1-
Which of the following contributed the most to the establishment of a separate homeland for Muslims?
  • Gandhi-Jinnah Talks;
  • Simla conference;
  • Cabinet Mission plan?
Explain your answer with reference to all three of the above.


It would be easier to answer if you can specify, is help needed in the format for attempting this question, or do you need to know what do we have to write/content of the answer?
 
Messages
129
Reaction score
23
Points
18
CAN ANYONE HELPPPP
Format:
  • A 14 mark question requires 7 explanations.
  • Explain all the events in order
  • Make sure that you have 7 explanations.
Content
The content depends on the books you are using, it doesn't matter what book is being used as long as the content is right.
I will refer you the pages from the books I use.

- My recommended format:
. 3 explanations Gandi-Jinnah talks
. 2 explanations Simla Conference
.2 explanations Cabinet Misson Plan

* Refer M/J/18 Q.3 (c) mark scheme to better know how to develop points.

Gandhi Jinnah Talks.
*Explain the terms along with the reasons they were outright rejected by Jinnah.
*Any 3 terms along with their reasons for rejection.
Farooq Bajwa's book, Page 127-128
. Gandhi's claim although he did not speak....nation (page 127)
. Gandhi's desire that..existence (Page 128)
. The major turning point.. self-determination was (Page 128)

Simla Conference :
*Explain the terms along with the reasons they were outright rejected by Jinnah.
(Attaching 2 images below)

1618665855306.png

1618665876383.png

Cabinet mission plan
. Explain the plans and proposals given by the plan, their rejection. (End at interim government)
Page 87-88 Nigel kelly

*These are only reccomendations, you are feel free to write anythig as long as it is relevant
*Best suggestion : Consult mark scheme of this question.
 
Messages
13
Reaction score
1
Points
3
Thanks alot.
Format:
  • A 14 mark question requires 7 explanations.
  • Explain all the events in order
  • Make sure that you have 7 explanations.
Content
The content depends on the books you are using, it doesn't matter what book is being used as long as the content is right.
I will refer you the pages from the books I use.

- My recommended format:
. 3 explanations Gandi-Jinnah talks
. 2 explanations Simla Conference
.2 explanations Cabinet Misson Plan

* Refer M/J/18 Q.3 (c) mark scheme to better know how to develop points.

Gandhi Jinnah Talks.
*Explain the terms along with the reasons they were outright rejected by Jinnah.
*Any 3 terms along with their reasons for rejection.
Farooq Bajwa's book, Page 127-128
. Gandhi's claim although he did not speak....nation (page 127)
. Gandhi's desire that..existence (Page 128)
. The major turning point.. self-determination was (Page 128)

Simla Conference :
*Explain the terms along with the reasons they were outright rejected by Jinnah.
(Attaching 2 images below)

View attachment 66021

View attachment 66022

Cabinet mission plan
. Explain the plans and proposals given by the plan, their rejection. (End at interim government)
Page 87-88 Nigel kelly

*These are only reccomendations, you are feel free to write anythig as long as it is relevant
*Best suggestion : Consult mark scheme of this question.
Thanks ALOTT
 
Top