Pakistan Studies, Islamiyat and Urdu: Post your doubts here!

[ElLa_Jan]

or do you just want the info?

 

[Iqra aftab]

'indian resistance to british attempts to take control was totally unsuccessful'. Do you agree? (14)
What do you mean by INDIAN RESISTANCE and how shall we answer this question?
PLZ HELP

 

[ElLa_Jan]

could you please mention the Year of the paper?

 

[Iqra aftab]

its june 2008 q 2c

 

[m7aug]

plz tell me how to start answer of this question "lucknow pact was the only hope for the people sub continet form 1909 t0 1919.do you agree or disagree?"
does any body know the link for ebook of history and culture of pakistan by kelly latest edition

 

[ElLa_Jan]

its june 2008 q 2c

By indian resistance, they mean the various efforts of the indian rulers to defeat the British. the events between 1750-1850.

as it is 14 marks, you have to give proper detail. start with a simplistic statement like

''The british gradually took control of the territories in the sub continent during 1750-1850, and all resistance failed.''


then u start one by one the events:
Battle of Plassey 1757, gained Bengal.
Battle of Buxar 1764, gained bihar and orissa.
the Mysore war( tipu sultan), gained south india
War against the marathas 1818, gained Deccan
annexation of sindh 1843,
annexation of punjab after Sikh War 1849
describe each in 3-5 lines, naming the people involved.

Then explain why the british were victorious, superior in weapons, organized army, funding from England, communication and spy system. on the other hand the indians lacked all this, and they had no leader and no planned army. give it 1 paragraph or a bit more.

end with a conclusion, similar to the starting statement.

Hope i cud help you!

 

[ElLa_Jan]

plz tell me how to start answer of this question "lucknow pact was the only hope for the people sub continet form 1909 t0 1919.do you agree or disagree?"
does any body know the link for ebook of history and culture of pakistan by kelly latest edition

this question? :
''The Lucknow Pact of 1916 was the only beacon of hope for Hindu-Muslim Unity between 1914-1930. do you agree? give reasons for your answer.''
november 2004 q2 c

 

[Hum199]

'indian resistance to british attempts to take control was totally unsuccessful'. Do you agree? (14)
What do you mean by INDIAN RESISTANCE and how shall we answer this question?
PLZ HELP

In my opinion.
-We just have to write about the British that how they took the territory of Indian subcontinent.
-Annexation of Sindh and Punjab.
-The wars between British and the Nawabs of Oudh and others.
-The doctrine of lapse, the policy which was made by British to take control of the subcontinent.
-And at last we just have to write about the Successes and failures Indian subcontinent in protecting their territory.
-Evaluation statement at the end.

Plz correct me if i m wrong!

 

[Hum199]

plz tell me how to start answer of this question "lucknow pact was the only hope for the people sub continet form 1909 t0 1919.do you agree or disagree?"
does any body know the link for ebook of history and culture of pakistan by kelly latest edition

In this we have to describe the following reforms:
-Morley-minto reforms 1909
-Montague Chelmsford reform 1919.
-Lucknow pact 1916 also

 

[ElLa_Jan]

In my opinion.
-We just have to write about the British that how they took the territory of Indian subcontinent.
-Annexation of Sindh and Punjab.
-The wars between British and the Nawabs of Oudh and others.
-The doctrine of lapse, the policy which was made by British to take control of the subcontinent.
-And at last we just have to write about the Successes and failures Indian subcontinent in protecting their territory.
-Evaluation statement at the end.

Plz correct me if i m wrong!

not wrong at all! i gave a bit of exlplanation, but my point was the same as you have mentioned!
the annexations, ''The wars between British and the Nawabs of Oudh and others'' is basically Plassey, Buxar and ''others'' are Marathas and Tipu Sultan!
and the rest, the concluion and why the indians were defeated.. So, you're answer is completely correct!

 

[Iqra aftab]

By indian resistance, they mean the various efforts of the indian rulers to defeat the British. the events between 1750-1850.

as it is 14 marks, you have to give proper detail. start with a simplistic statement like

''The british gradually took control of the territories in the sub continent during 1750-1850, and all resistance failed.''

then briefly state why they were there in the first place. trade etc.

then u start one by one the events:
Battle of Plassey 1757, gained Bengal.
Battle of Buxar 1764, gained bihar and orissa.
the Mysore war( tipu sultan), gained south india
War against the marathas 1818, gained Deccan
annexation of sindh 1843,
annexation of punjab after Sikh War 1849
describe each in 3-5 lines, naming the people involved.

Then explain why the british were victorious, superior in weapons, organized army, funding from England, communication and spy system. on the other hand the indians lacked all this, and they had no leader and no planned army. give it 1 paragraph or a bit more.

end with a conclusion, similar to the starting statement.

Hope i cud help you!

It waz helpful, Thanks for the help

 

[brainswipe]

'indian resistance to british attempts to take control was totally unsuccessful'. Do you agree? (14)
What do you mean by INDIAN RESISTANCE and how shall we answer this question?
PLZ HELP

THIS IS AN UNSTRUCTURED QUESTION, i.e that there are no marks for UNDERSTANDING.
in this question the pattern will be:-
10 marks for knowledge + 4 marks for evaluation
lets divide the question into two halves:-
Failure:-
battle of plassey
battle of buxar
annexation of oudh
annexation of sindh
annexation of punjab
defeat of tipu sultan
defeat of marathas

Successes:-
defeat of EIC from Haider ali
the threat of Rangit Singh
loss of three or two wars from indo-afghanistan

in the END give the evaluation statement that is the failure of indians.
NOTE:- the question is 'HOW' not 'WHY' that means no explanation is to be given only description!!

 

[ElLa_Jan]

THIS IS AN UNSTRUCTURED QUESTION, i.e that there are no marks for UNDERSTANDING.
in this question the pattern will be:-
10 marks for knowledge + 4 marks for evaluation
lets divide the question into two halves:-
Failure:-
battle of plassey
battle of buxar
annexation of oudh
annexation of sindh
annexation of punjab
defeat of tipu sultan
defeat of marathas

Successes:-
defeat of EIC from Haider ali
the threat of Rangit Singh
loss of three or two wars from indo-afghanistan

well i wasnt explaining structure.. i was explaining wat facts go in this answer! and i studied that from the Yearly Worked Solutions book by REDSPOT Publishing, for GCE O LEVEL. further, in my opinion, its better to give a consolidated answer than two halves.

 

[brainswipe]

well i wasnt explaining structure.. i was explaining wat facts go in this answer! and i studied that from the Yearly Worked Solutions book by REDSPOT Publishing, for GCE O LEVE.

I recommend you to throw away the worked solution of especially REDSPOT!!

 

[ElLa_Jan]

I recommend you to throw away the worked solution of especially REDSPOT!!

really? Why?

 

[brainswipe]

ALL those answer are wrong and even if you write those answer with exact accuracy in CIE i assure YOU ON MY LIFE THAT WILL ONLY MAKE YOU GAIN 5 OUT OF 7 OR 6 OUT OF 14.!!!! IF IT ISNT LIKE THAT I AM PREPARED TO DIE I PROMISE YOU!!!

 

[ElLa_Jan]

ALL those answer are wrong and even if you write those answer with exact accuracy in CIE i assure YOU ON MY LIFE THAT WILL ONLY MAKE YOU GAIN 5 OUT OF 7 OR 6 OUT OF 14.!!!! IF IT ISNT LIKE THAT I AM PREPARED TO DIE I PROMISE YOU!!!

hey, no dyng! our teacher used that book too, that why i use it. Why do you say its wrong? (asking so i can stop my friends aswell!)

 

[brainswipe]

well i wasnt explaining structure.. i was explaining wat facts go in this answer! and i studied that from the Yearly Worked Solutions book by REDSPOT Publishing, for GCE O LEVEL. further, in my opinion, its better to give a consolidated answer than two halves.

I THINK you need to work a lot dude!!!! YOU still haven't understand ed the 14 mark answer pattern correctly!!
to make you understand write to me the most easiest question of HISTORY may it be 7 mark or 14 marks!!!

 

[Daniyal Ahmed]

r u sure??

 

[Daniyal Ahmed]

r u sure??

i have learnt most of my thing from redspot