• We need your support!

    We are currently struggling to cover the operational costs of Xtremepapers, as a result we might have to shut this website down. Please donate if we have helped you and help make a difference in other students' lives!
    Click here to Donate Now (View Announcement)

Who shall enter Jannah?

Who do you think can enter Jannah? You can choose more than 1 option

  • Only Allah knows.

    Votes: 26 86.7%

  • Anyone who said La-Ilaha-Illala.. sincerly with this heart

    Votes: 13 43.3%

  • Good people from non-muslims too, like Mother Theresa,etc....

    Votes: 3 10.0%

  • A muslim who said La-ilaha illala... but still committed crimes.

    Votes: 3 10.0%
  • Total voters
    30
T

Toblerone

Messages
1,318
Reaction score
5,029
Points
523
Maganius said:
Mate mate mate, I've told countless times we are no one to Judge anyone, why dont you ppl just admit it. Allah knows whom to forgive or whom to not.
So Please Just Leave the part who will enter Jannah n who will not.
Our top Most Priority should be to teach other Islamic Values rather than arguing over something which need notto worry, C'mon we re Muslims so why the heck are we discussing such things,

Just stick to Islamic Values, NothingElse.Thanks
Nayya Hassan hope so this justifies it
Click to expand...

Very well said, Maganius. Very well said. (y)
I think everyone should consider this point and finish this endless argument here.
 
Afzal1

Afzal1

Messages
1,422
Reaction score
3,159
Points
273
Nabeel.Ahmad said:
Allah can do as He wills, he can forgive who He wills and punish Whom He wills and there is no one that can stop Him.
All i'm saying is there is no definite rule that all Non-Muslims are bound to be thrown into hell, as proved by the previous example discussed in this thread about that prostitute who fed a hungry dog and went to heaven. She was not a Muslim. That is, she was a Non-Muslim, and she went to heaven, just for doing a simple good deed. That proves that not all Non-Muslims will go to hell, and not all Muslims will go to heaven. Even for Muslims there are 4 things that are required in order to go to heaven. The entire fate of every single human lies in the hands of Allah, and Allah alone. We are no one to decide that Non-Muslims will go to hell or not.

And as i said before, not all Non-Muslims do Shirk, correct your misconception about this.

As told in the Quran about the Non-Muslims referred to as the ''people of the book'':

''Not all of them are alike: Of the People of the Book are a portion that stand (For the right): They rehearse the Signs of Allah all night long, and they prostrate themselves in adoration. (3:113)''

And also,

Ye are the best of peoples, evolved for mankind, enjoining what is right, forbidding what is wrong, and believing in Allah. If only the ''People of the Book'' had faith, it were best for them: among them are some who have faith, but most of them are perverted transgressors. (3:110)

And there are, certainly, among the People of the Book, those who believe in Allah, in the revelation to you, and in the revelation to them, bowing in humility to Allah: They will not sell the Signs of Allah for a miserable gain! For them is a reward with their Lord, and Allah is swift in account. (3:199)

Before labeling all Non-Muslims as destined for Hell, clear your concept about them. Not all of them do Shirk, as mentioned above in the verses.
And that prostitute went to heaven, didn't she!
Doesn't that prove that Allah can do whatever He wants.
We are no ones to make the rule that Non-Muslims can't go to heaven, or all Muslims will go to heaven.
Click to expand...

brother... the tafsir yo both the ayyatt suggests that '' the people of the book referred here are the people who FOLLOWED THE PROPHET MUSA AND ISA AT THEIR TIME PERIOD.... and these people are Muslims not Non - Muslims. The people who followed their prophets are referred to Muslims not kafirs.... but now The last and Final Messenger should be followed ONLY.... TO ENTER JANNAH. i also told you clearly that the previous books prophesised the coming of Muhammad as a prophet to all of mankind and to whom everyone should follow.

HOW CAN U SAY THAT NON - MUSLIMS WILL NOT ENTER HELL - FIRE...... Brother these people are doing Shirk....
Allah says in the Quran.... in luqman 31 Indeed Shirk is a great injustice to Allah....
also Allah says Do not take partners other thatn Allah for anyone who takes partners other than Allah.... ALLAH WILL MAKE JANNAH HARRAAM FOR HIM.

see brother the point that Allah and HIS messenger are trying to hghlight in that hadith is about the BEING MERCIFUL TO THE LIVING CREATURES.... the point here is that this prostitute was not a KAFIR.... she was a muslim.... so Allah forgave her because she did not commit SHIRK.... which Allah will never forgive. Allah HIMSELF SAYS THAT
 
Nabeel.Ahmad

Nabeel.Ahmad

Messages
3,091
Reaction score
8,272
Points
523
Afzal1 said:
brother... the tafsir yo both the ayyatt suggests that '' the people of the book referred here are the people who FOLLOWED THE PROPHET MUSA AND ISA AT THEIR TIME PERIOD.... and these people are Muslims not Non - Muslims. The people who followed their prophets are referred to Muslims not kafirs.... but now The last and Final Messenger should be followed ONLY.... TO ENTER JANNAH. i also told you clearly that the previous books prophesised the coming of Muhammad as a prophet to all of mankind and to whom everyone should follow.

HOW CAN U SAY THAT NON - MUSLIMS WILL NOT ENTER HELL - FIRE...... Brother these people are doing Shirk....
Allah says in the Quran.... in luqman 31 Indeed Shirk is a great injustice to Allah....
also Allah says Do not take partners other thatn Allah for anyone who takes partners other than Allah.... ALLAH WILL MAKE JANNAH HARRAAM FOR HIM.

see brother the point that Allah and HIS messenger are trying to hghlight in that hadith is about the BEING MERCIFUL TO THE LIVING CREATURES.... the point here is that this prostitute was not a KAFIR.... she was a muslim.... so Allah forgave her because she did not commit SHIRK.... which Allah will never forgive. Allah HIMSELF SAYS THAT
Click to expand...


A PROSTITUTE went to heaven. She was committing the most disgraceful of sins, and she went to heaven for one simple good deed.
That means Allah can do whatever He wants. He has never made a ruling that every single Non-Muslim will go to hell.
People who commit shirk will not go to heaven, and even that before they become Muslims. If someone converts to Islam, all his previous sins will be wiped away.
Allah is the one who can see through the hearts of men and decide who's intentions are what.
Have you ever talked a Christian? How do you know they are committing Shirk? Based on what you have heard?
Get some real information, man.
Just like in Islam, there are Christian sects too.

I'm no way saying that people who do Shirk will go to heaven, Nauzubillah.
The point of our conflict lies in the difference between Shirk and Non-Muslims. Not all Non-Muslims commit shirk. Please do a little more research about this before posting here.

The entire fate of every human being lies in the hands of Allah. He can forgive whomever He wants. And punish whomever he wants.
NOT all Muslims will go to heaven, there is a criteria for us too. There are 4 points that will be judged about Muslims as well, before we enter heaven.
Same way, you or anyone else is no one to make the ruling that Non-Muslims will be thrown into Hell. Only Allah, the most Merciful, Most-Gracious can decide that. That's all i'm saying, Brother.
 
Afzal1

Afzal1

Messages
1,422
Reaction score
3,159
Points
273
Nabeel.Ahmad said:
A PROSTITUTE went to heaven. She was committing the most disgraceful of sins, and she went to heaven for one simple good deed.
That means Allah can do whatever He wants. He has never made a ruling that every single Non-Muslim will go to hell.
People who commit shirk will not go to heaven, and even that before they become Muslims. If someone converts to Islam, all his previous sins will be wiped away.
Allah is the one who can see through the hearts of men and decide who's intentions are what.
Have you ever talked a Christian? How do you know they are committing Shirk? Based on what you have heard?
Get some real information, man.
Just like in Islam, there are Christian sects too.

I'm no way saying that people who do Shirk will go to heaven, Nauzubillah.
The point of our conflict lies in the difference between Shirk and Non-Muslims. Not all Non-Muslims commit shirk. Please do a little more research about this before posting here.

The entire fate of every human being lies in the hands of Allah. He can forgive whomever He wants. And punish whomever he wants.
NOT all Muslims will go to heaven, there is a criteria for us too. There are 4 points that will be judged about Muslims as well, before we enter heaven.
Same way, you or anyone else is no one to make the ruling that Non-Muslims will be thrown into Hell. Only Allah, the most Merciful, Most-Gracious can decide that. That's all i'm saying, Brother.
Click to expand...



leave it.... even if i tell u... u are not going to understand..... :D
 
1357911

1357911

Messages
2,332
Reaction score
9,506
Points
523
Maganius said:
Mate mate mate, I've told countless times we are no one to Judge anyone, why dont you ppl just admit it. Allah knows whom to forgive or whom to not.
So Please Just Leave the part who will enter Jannah n who will not.
Our top Most Priority should be to teach other Islamic Values rather than arguing over something which need notto worry, C'mon we re Muslims so why the heck are we discussing such things,

Just stick to Islamic Values, NothingElse.Thanks
Nayya Hassan hope so this justifies it
Click to expand...

We arent here to judge people Maganius and they arent judging anyone. Read what they are trying to say.
 
Hassan Ali Abid

Hassan Ali Abid

Messages
1,160
Reaction score
3,858
Points
273
No one exactly knows who will enter jannah.Every thing is in the hand of Allah.Discussing such things here will just cause the fithna among muslims.No one will either enter jannah or hell by the debates of you people .
and the person who made this thread shouldnt have done this and members should have snubed him as he has made this thread whose discussion is so controversial.
 
Ahmedraza73

Ahmedraza73

Messages
1,442
Reaction score
7,812
Points
523
abdxyz Fayax555 ***amd***
Assalam-U-Alaikum

Brothers please stop fighting here,what you people are doing,we are muslim, we can not fight like this,you people showing your weaknees to others and allowing third person to argue on this matter
The one who will enter the jannah will not be decided by we people,but yup we know,what isalmic quranic and hadith teachings are taughting us are the rightest and will give a way to jannah.Just first simply act on them,cause arguing to others is very simple,
Each of everyone of us will have to answer for our own Deeds at the day of judgment.So leave who will enter jannah and who will not. First act on isalmic teachings and Understand Quran

abdxyz thread was good bro,just some of your polls make it wrong to the people.:):)
 
Maganius

Maganius

Messages
4,734
Reaction score
42,095
Points
523
Ahmedraza73 said:
abdxyz Fayax555 ***amd***
Assalam-U-Alaikum

Brothers please stop fighting here,what you people are doing,we are muslim, we can not fight like this,you people showing your weaknees to others and allowing third person to argue on this matter
The one who will enter the jannah will not be decided by we people,but yup we know,what isalmic quranic and hadith teachings are taughting us are the rightest and will give a way to jannah.Just first simply act on them,cause arguing to others is very simple,
Each of everyone of us will have to answer for our own Deeds at the day of judgment.So leave who will enter jannah and who will not. First act on isalmic teachings and Understand Quran

abdxyz thread was good bro,just some of your polls make it wrong to the people.:):)
Click to expand...

Thats what im trying to say to em :)
 
A

***amd***

Messages
3,401
Reaction score
9,793
Points
523
Ahmedraza73 said:
abdxyz Fayax555 ***amd***
Assalam-U-Alaikum

Brothers please stop fighting here,what you people are doing,we are muslim, we can not fight like this,you people showing your weaknees to others and allowing third person to argue on this matter
The one who will enter the jannah will not be decided by we people,but yup we know,what isalmic quranic and hadith teachings are taughting us are the rightest and will give a way to jannah.Just first simply act on them,cause arguing to others is very simple,
Each of everyone of us will have to answer for our own Deeds at the day of judgment.So leave who will enter jannah and who will not. First act on isalmic teachings and Understand Quran

abdxyz thread was good bro,just some of your polls make it wrong to the people.:):)
Click to expand...

well i had already said the same :D btw (y)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top