BAN MUSIC CAMPAIGN - For Muslim brothers and sisters

[plantaholic]

actually listening isnt a use, when u use something u touch it as far as i know

when you're only "listening" to musical instruments, then you're actually promoting their use..(since the sound from any instrument can only come when it is "touched" and played according to your logic )... and in doing that, you're supporting a gunnah...
so either way, its haraam.. you've no other way out..

 

[umarashraf]

Idk maybe it was translated wrong, give me the Arabic version plz

Sahih BUkhari verse no. 5590 Vol no.7

 

[Haris Bin Zahid]

SalmanPakRocks, XPFMember, badrobot14 or any Mod or Administrator....kindly make this thread sticky so that everyone could get guidance from the Hadiths and Quranic verses our Muslim brothers and sisters have posted. It's a request.May Allah guide us all to the right path.
Em really grateful to XPFMember for highlighting this issue, as each and everyone (even sincere Muslims) listen to music these days.
Well....I never had an interest for listening to music since I was born....but will try my best to convince all those around me to stop listening to music.
XPFMember: kindly include me in your first post of this topic.

 

[plantaholic]

this is stupid ...music is not Haram !
abey yaar ghar mein beewi nahi hai to idhar frustration utar rahe ho ....sad
wailay mustanday ho tum

it would be better if you did a little investigation yourself..and please be careful before passing any such statement... you just rejected clear orders of the Prophet (S.A.W.).. if you are not convinced ok, but please do not post comments like these...

 

[Ahmedfj]

this is stupid ...music is not Haram !
abey yaar ghar mein beewi nahi hai to idhar frustration utar rahe ho ....sad
wailay mustanday ho tum

got any proofs ??? .. coz statements without proofs are called "Bongiyaan"

 

[haroon740]

it would be better if you did a little investigation yourself..and please be careful before passing any such statement... you just rejected clear orders of the Prophet (S.A.W.).. if you are not convinced ok, but please do not post comments like these...

lisin I have done enuf research to make me aware of wht is right nd whts not
Allah gave prophet the miracle of a beautiful melodious voice ....how can Allah choose a haram thing fow His own praise ! -,-

 

[Ahmedfj]

lisin I have done enuf research to make me aware of wht is right nd whts not
Allah gave prophet the miracle of a beautiful melodious voice ....how can Allah choose a haram thing fow His own praise ! -,-

Ur vocal cords r musical instruments too but they are .not haram coz religiously they arnt mentioned in prohibitions and scientofically their normal usage coz u no harm unlike the artificial musical instruments

 

[Ahmedfj]

lisin I have done enuf research to make me aware of wht is right nd whts not
Allah gave prophet the miracle of a beautiful melodious voice ....how can Allah choose a haram thing fow His own praise ! -,-

btw ur argument was predicted by holy prophet in sahih bukhari book of drinks hadith 494

 

[plantaholic]

lisin I have done enuf research to make me aware of wht is right nd whts not
Allah gave prophet the miracle of a beautiful melodious voice ....how can Allah choose a haram thing fow His own praise ! -,-

melodious voice is one thing and music from instruments another.. if you want to listen to music, by all means go ahead. no one can persuade any one unless Allah decrees it.. everyone is free to make his choices.. this thread is not forcing you. and you should respect others arguments too, instead of ridiculing and posting inappropraite comments.. by the way what do you think of all the ahadees posted above in this thread? the ones about the singing and dancing women becoming numerous near Qayamah?

 

[umarashraf]

lisin I have done enuf research to make me aware of wht is right nd whts not
Allah gave prophet the miracle of a beautiful melodious voice ....how can Allah choose a haram thing fow His own praise ! -,-

Holy Quran is not the only source guidance for mankind..... Its been clearly written in the Sahih Bukhari Vol no7 Verse no. 5590... that ...

Narrated Abu Amir or Abu Malik Al Ashari that he heard the Prophet saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical instruments, as lawful for them....​

I think this clearly outlines problems associated with music....
Sahih BUkhari verse no. 5590 Vol no.7

 

[haroon740]

Holy Quran is not the only source guidance for mankind..... Its been clearly written in the Sahih Bukhari Vol no7 Verse no. 5590... that ...

Narrated Abu Amir or Abu Malik Al Ashari that he heard the Prophet saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical instruments, as lawful for them....​

I think this clearly outlines problems associated with music....
Sahih BUkhari verse no. 5590 Vol no.7

I THINK WE ARE ALL SMART ENOUGH TO KNOW THAT BY FAR QURAN IS BEST SOURCE OF GUIDANCE COMPARED TO ANY OTHER HADITH ......CZ QURAN IS LANGUAGE OF ALLAH (SWT) AND I'M HERE TO GIVE MY OPINION OKAI SO U TEEN MULLAS SHOULD NOT TAKE OFFENCE IF SOMEONE OPPOSES UR THOUGHTS ...AND I'M CONTRADICTING WITH REASON SO NO ONE HAS THE RIGHT TO SAY THAT I'M OFFENDING THEIR THOUGHTS ....WE ALL HAVE THE FREEDOOM OF SPEECH -,-

 

[Ahmedfj]

I THINK WE ARE ALL SMART ENOUGH TO KNOW THAT BY FAR QURAN IS BEST SOURCE OF GUIDANCE COMPARED TO ANY OTHER HADITH ......CZ QURAN IS LANGUAGE OF ALLAH (SWT) AND I'M HERE TO GIVE MY OPINION OKAI SO U TEEN MULLAS SHOULD NOT TAKE OFFENCE IF SOMEONE OPPOSES UR THOUGHTS ...AND I'M CONTRADICTING WITH REASON SO NO ONE HAS THE RIGHT TO SAY THAT I'M OFFENDING THEIR THOUGHTS ....WE ALL HAVE THE FREEDOOM OF SPEECH -,-

and in my last post I explained the self contradictory reason through which u r contradicting .. btw no one is forcing but freedom of speech doesnt mean that u go on disrespecting others by posting such type of comments which u have to delete afterwards

 

[SalmanPakRocks]

I THINK WE ARE ALL SMART ENOUGH TO KNOW THAT BY FAR QURAN IS BEST SOURCE OF GUIDANCE COMPARED TO ANY OTHER HADITH ......CZ QURAN IS LANGUAGE OF ALLAH (SWT) AND I'M HERE TO GIVE MY OPINION OKAI SO U TEEN MULLAS SHOULD NOT TAKE OFFENCE IF SOMEONE OPPOSES UR THOUGHTS ...AND I'M CONTRADICTING WITH REASON SO NO ONE HAS THE RIGHT TO SAY THAT I'M OFFENDING THEIR THOUGHTS ....WE ALL HAVE THE FREEDOOM OF SPEECH -,-

Read the rule dude, block letter is considered shouting. :/
And if you don't agree with something. It's better not to start an 'argument'.

 

[aTraveller]

Assalamoalaikum wr wb!

Well, most of you already know that music is Haraam in Islam...

This thread is for those interested to leave music...cuz once you're addicted, you might have to struggle if you decide to leave it..

Let's say we'll have points thing...like +10 if you spent the whole day without listening, and -1 for each song you heard
Lets see who gets the most points
It's like competing, may be this'll help you alll in giving up listening to music

..or may be if you got some better idea we'd do here altogether, do share ....
and not to mention, be honest


P.S. Adopted from Narcotic's idea she said something like ban music campaign, and i thought good one

And a good reminder...save yourself:

View attachment 6320​

PARTICIPANTS:

skull gurl
duaazahra
SalmanPakRocks
memyself15
purplerox
smzimran
hafsahassan
Yours Truly
HauteHijabii
Dexterwarrior12
iblue
-7 domination-
umaima patwari
ayeshaddy
Artemis

Is it too late? I wanna participate too

 

[badrobot14]

Is it too late? I wanna participate too

yes youy can. As they say, it's never too late... (I've no idea y they say that.)

 

[plantaholic]

I THINK WE ARE ALL SMART ENOUGH TO KNOW THAT BY FAR QURAN IS BEST SOURCE OF GUIDANCE COMPARED TO ANY OTHER HADITH ......CZ QURAN IS LANGUAGE OF ALLAH (SWT) AND I'M HERE TO GIVE MY OPINION OKAI SO U TEEN MULLAS SHOULD NOT TAKE OFFENCE IF SOMEONE OPPOSES UR THOUGHTS ...AND I'M CONTRADICTING WITH REASON SO NO ONE HAS THE RIGHT TO SAY THAT I'M OFFENDING THEIR THOUGHTS ....WE ALL HAVE THE FREEDOOM OF SPEECH -,-

but freedom of speech comes with some ethical limits.. and btw, it was not the 'teen mullas' giving offence in the first place..

 

[plantaholic]

I THINK WE ARE ALL SMART ENOUGH TO KNOW THAT BY FAR QURAN IS BEST SOURCE OF GUIDANCE COMPARED TO ANY OTHER HADITH ......CZ QURAN IS LANGUAGE OF ALLAH (SWT) AND I'M HERE TO GIVE MY OPINION OKAI SO U TEEN MULLAS SHOULD NOT TAKE OFFENCE IF SOMEONE OPPOSES UR THOUGHTS ...AND I'M CONTRADICTING WITH REASON SO NO ONE HAS THE RIGHT TO SAY THAT I'M OFFENDING THEIR THOUGHTS ....WE ALL HAVE THE FREEDOOM OF SPEECH -,-

you are right, Quran is the Supreme Word of Allah, but hey! didn't Allah say in the Quran that follow Me and the Prophet (P.B.U.H)? every aspect of life is not dealt with in detail in the Quran, you have to seek guidance from Sunnah and Ahadees.. you have to take them side by side and not leave either one behind.. people usually do that when they want to come up with an excuse for their unjustified judgements and actions.. May Allah guide us all. Aameen!

 

[umarashraf]

I THINK WE ARE ALL SMART ENOUGH TO KNOW THAT BY FAR QURAN IS BEST SOURCE OF GUIDANCE COMPARED TO ANY OTHER HADITH ......CZ QURAN IS LANGUAGE OF ALLAH (SWT) AND I'M HERE TO GIVE MY OPINION OKAI SO U TEEN MULLAS SHOULD NOT TAKE OFFENCE IF SOMEONE OPPOSES UR THOUGHTS ...AND I'M CONTRADICTING WITH REASON SO NO ONE HAS THE RIGHT TO SAY THAT I'M OFFENDING THEIR THOUGHTS ....WE ALL HAVE THE FREEDOOM OF SPEECH -,-

COME ON MATE... there is nothing to be angry abt here... everyone will meet the truth on the day of judgement... okay lets join the different side of the story, do you feel any positive outcome from musics..??? if its nothing bad in it then is there anything positive in it..??? mate there are certain things Quran donot deal with... if this was All-boys forum then i would have surely commented on these certain things as well... hope you may understand..

 

[badrobot14]

I THINK WE ARE ALL SMART ENOUGH TO KNOW THAT BY FAR QURAN IS BEST SOURCE OF GUIDANCE COMPARED TO ANY OTHER HADITH ......CZ QURAN IS LANGUAGE OF ALLAH (SWT) AND I'M HERE TO GIVE MY OPINION OKAI SO U TEEN MULLAS SHOULD NOT TAKE OFFENCE IF SOMEONE OPPOSES UR THOUGHTS ...AND I'M CONTRADICTING WITH REASON SO NO ONE HAS THE RIGHT TO SAY THAT I'M OFFENDING THEIR THOUGHTS ....WE ALL HAVE THE FREEDOOM OF SPEECH -,-

Although the most illogical thing to say would be that I believe in Quran not in Hadith.. since Quran tells us: "But no, by your Lord, they will not [truly] believe until they make you, [O Muhammad], judge concerning that over which they dispute among themselves and then find within themselves no discomfort from what you have judged and submit in [full, willing] submission." (4:65)

but, even Quran mentions music, although indirectly:
"And of the people is he who buys the amusement of speech to mislead [others] from the way of Allah without knowledge and who takes it in ridicule. Those will have a humiliating punishment." (31:6)

Ibn Mas`ud (RA) commented about the Ayah:
(And of mankind is he who purchases Lahu Al-Hadith to mislead (men) from the path of Allah), he said, "This -- by Allah -- refers to singing.''
[source: tafsir ibn kathir]

---------------
My advice: if you find an injunction of Islam difficult to follow, don't say 'it is not haram etc.' rather have it in your heart that insha'Allah one day I'll fix myself... knowing wrong as wrong is the first step to fixing it.

 

[plantaholic]

Although the most illogical thing to say would be that I believe in Quran not in Hadith.. since Quran tells us: "But no, by your Lord, they will not [truly] believe until they make you, [O Muhammad], judge concerning that over which they dispute among themselves and then find within themselves no discomfort from what you have judged and submit in [full, willing] submission." (4:65)

but, even Quran mentions music, although indirectly:
"And of the people is he who buys the amusement of speech to mislead [others] from the way of Allah without knowledge and who takes it in ridicule. Those will have a humiliating punishment." (31:6)

Ibn Mas`ud (RA) commented about the Ayah:
(And of mankind is he who purchases Lahu Al-Hadith to mislead (men) from the path of Allah), he said, "This -- by Allah -- refers to singing.''
[source: tafsir ibn kathir]

---------------
My advice: if you find an injunction of Islam difficult to follow, don't say 'it is not haram etc.' rather have it in your heart that insha'Allah one day I'll fix myself... knowing wrong as wrong is the first step to fixing it.

i like your advice.. thats the key to sparking change within oneself