- Messages
- 1,594
- Reaction score
- 483
- Points
- 93
Here's an MCQ:
Gaseous particle X has a proton number n and a charge of +1.
Gaseous particle Y has a proton number (n+1) and is isoelectronic with (has the same number of electrons as) X.
Which statement correctly describes X and Y?
1. X has a large radius than Y.
2. X requires more energy than Y when another electron is removed from each particle.
3. X releases more energy than Y when an electron is added to each particle.
The correct answer is that '1 only is correct'. The logic given by our teacher was that atomic radii decrease across a period and since X precedes Y, 1 is correct.
I somehow remain unconvinced.
Gaseous particle X has a proton number n and a charge of +1.
Gaseous particle Y has a proton number (n+1) and is isoelectronic with (has the same number of electrons as) X.
Which statement correctly describes X and Y?
1. X has a large radius than Y.
2. X requires more energy than Y when another electron is removed from each particle.
3. X releases more energy than Y when an electron is added to each particle.
The correct answer is that '1 only is correct'. The logic given by our teacher was that atomic radii decrease across a period and since X precedes Y, 1 is correct.
I somehow remain unconvinced.